No, under these facts you do not have a bad faith claim. Insurance companies have the sole discretion to settle a case or not..A nuisance value settlement is just that - minimal amount of money to ditch a lousy case rather than spend a ton to fight it in court..There is nothing you can do about it..I understand your moral issue about giving a meth addict money for something she provoked, but there are other issues at play..You just have to let it go and be glad you aren't wasting more time in depositions, discovery and appearing at trial...Dog bites are tricky and the issues aren't as clear cut as you might think, to your detriment...
Legal disclaimer: Please be advised that the advice provided does not create any attorney/client relationship; that due to the various state laws that the information provided is a general overview of the law, which might not be applicable to you, based upon the laws of your state. We will not file anything on your behalf nor protect any statute of limitations which might arise and recommend that you IMMEDIATELY consult legal counsel for adviceThis response does not constitute or make an attorney-client relationship as it is made for general purposes; answering attorney does not possess enough information to inform recipient of the applicable statute of limitations. You may also contact Mr. Hiden at (619) 296-5884 or by email at "firstname.lastname@example.org"
I do not think you have a bad faith claim unless the actions of your company cause you to lose money. It sounds like your insurance company has made a business decision to pay a minimal amount and avoid the possibility of future expensive litigation that you would win after spending a lot of time money and effort. Per your policy language, they have the right make settlement offers on claims they find appropriate. Your company has decided to pay a very small amount now to avoid spending more money later.
Based on the facts that you describe it does not appear that you have a bad faith on your hands. A bad faith claim would arise if your insurance company was not protecting your interests based on your contractual agreement. In fact, by paying out a minimal amount, they are actually protecting you from being personally liable for any damages caused to the young woman. Based on California law regarding dog bites, you could be held responsible for her medical bills and pain and suffering. Once she accepts the settlement offer from your insurance company, she will sign away any claim for further compensation. Good luck!
Bergener & Associates | 1-800-881-2021 | email@example.com | http://www.bergenerlaw.com | The information provided must not be considered legal advice. Comments made on websites such as Avvo.com are provided for information purposes only. Bergener & Associates, PLC is a personal injury practice serving accident victims and their families in the State of California only. No individuals should act or refrain from acting on the basis of any answers to questions without seeking the appropriate legal or other professional advice from an attorney licensed in their state. This communication does not create an attorney-client relationship between any attorney at Bergener & Associates and any recipient.
Your ins co has a duty to protect its insured, you, from being sued or having a judgment against you. They are trying to do that by settling. They also don't want to waste money and your time by having to fight the case in court. If you don't like it talk to them about releasing them from any obligation on the claim so you can hire your own atty to fight the case. I wouldn't recommend you do that.
You are not, and it's hard for anyone in your position to be, objective. Were it your money, I am confidant that you wouldn't be nearly so inclined to play hard ball. You knew the woman was your visitor and presumably quickly perceived her meth-type behavior. Your dog seems blameless, but you may not be. Remember, the woman is a meth user and thus probably isn't rational and certainly is just as non-objective. Move on.
If you think you need a bad faith attorney then you should consult with a bad faith attorney in your jurisdiction to find out if you are right. Consult competent counsel if you require more information for your specific situation.
Sign up to receive a 3-part series of useful information and advice about personal injury law.