"[U]nless the question bears a direct and substantial relationship to the position for which the person is being considered." This is the catch-all provision/exception to the statute. I believe the Ohio bar will take the position that you have to disclose and expunged or sealed record, because it bears on your character and fitness to practice law.
You appear to be the same person who made a similar inquiry a few days ago on this subject. The bottom line, in my opinion, is that you should disclose your record, rather than take the position that you are not required to disclose it. Contrary to what many lay people believe, lawyers are held to high standards, and people who seek a license to practice law are expected to be scrupulously honest when answering questions on a bar application.
Again, if you are reluctant to make the disclosure, you should consult privately with an attorney in Ohio about the details of your situation. I think that disclosing the information will not necessarily disqualify you from obtaining a license. But holding back the information probably will. Good luck.
The response I have provided is general in nature, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. My practice is based in Rhode Island, and the law and practice in other states or jurisdictions may be different.
The Supreme Court of Ohio would likely argue that any charge, whether a sealed dismissal or conviction is relevant to your character and fitness to become a license attorney in Ohio. They would likely additionally argue that said information, coupled with new disciplinary conduct, is relevant to a determination as to whether to suspend or revoke your license to practice.
I have been on the committee who does these character and fitness interviews for 5 or so years now. You are not asking the right question or really taking the right approach here. IF you have ANY charge, you have a DUTY to disclose it. IF you lie about it, well THAT is the think that impacts your character and fitness. Your failure to disclose or attempt to cover something up are FAR more important. The fact that you had a prior charge CAN also prohibit you from practicing. It depends. I had a friend who could not practice in Ohio because she had a Marijuana charge from high school, however she was able to practice in a different state, with NO problems. End of the day, it depends on what you have been charged with. GOOD LUCK.
The above information is not, nor intend to be, legal advice. You SHOULD consult an attorney for specific advice regarding your individual situation. Based on this response no attorney-client relationship has been formed. If your matter is in Cuyahoga County or surrounding counties, we invite you to contact us. Please visit our website at www.kirnerandboldt.com. Contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please do not send any confidential information until such time and attorney-client relationship is formed. Attorneys in this firm are only licensed to practice in the state of Ohio and have no specific information as to the laws and rules of other states and none of the information provided is intended to be applied to the laws of other states.