A violation is not a criminal offense and does not leave the defendant with a criminal record. However, a person can choose not to hire you for any reason other than a constitutionally-protected reason (age, race, gender, etc etc) So they can ask if you have ever been convicted of a violation and choose not to hire you because once in the last three years you were found guilty of acting disorderly. He can choose not to hire you because you wore a red shirt to the interview.Ask a similar question
In NYS Disorderly Conduct is one of the most confusing and difficult to describe prohibited offenses. As you stated a violation is not a "crime" (misdemeanors and felonies are crimes). However, it is a prohibited action contained in the NYS Penal Law (NYS criminal code). So, one can be convicted of Disorderly Conduct and not have committed a "crime", but have violated the Penal Law (Criminal Law). Thus, a question posed as "have you ever been convicted of a crime" can be answered in the negative; but, a question posed as "have you ever been convicted of having committed a criminal offense" is a bit more difficult to parse.
Also, in NYS convictions for Disorderly Conduct should be "sealed" by the court involved. Sometimes this isn't automatically done (though it should be) bedause the court did not issue a sealing order. However, a sealing order issued by a state court can only bind state/local police agencies. It cannot bind federal agencies, like the FBI, who actually never get rid of information about arrests, even though they will say the voluntarily abide by state seailng orders.Ask a similar question