Overall Rating
This is an aggregated review score of Avvo and Lawyers.com reviews.

5.0 /5.0

101 Client Reviews

Avvo

5.0

(92)

Lawyers.com

5.0

(9 )

 See client reviews from Lawyers.com
Filter Avvo Reviews (92) Refine reviews to match your needs. Use the filters to quickly surface reviews that align with your case or priorities.
Star rating
5 stars 91
4 stars 0
3 stars 0
2 stars 0
1 star 1
Practice Areas
Lawsuits & Disputes (39) Personal Injury (35) Car Accidents (23) Insurance (12) Litigation (5) Mediation (2) Motorcycle Accident (2) Slip and Fall Accident (2) Trucking Accident (2) Animal & Dog Bites (1) Criminal Defense (1) DUI & DWI (1) Nursing Home Abuse and Neglect (1) Violent Crime (1)
What Clients Mention
Case Results (60) Advocacy (45) Recommendation (38) Responsiveness (35) Communication Style (32) Professionalism (32) Trustworthiness (26) Character & Conduct (25) Compassion (19) Practice Area Knowledge (19) General Knowledge (15) Staff & Support (11) Cost of Services (4) Punctuality (2)

Showing 41 - 45 of 60 reviews | Case Results

Posted by Clive | June 02, 2015

Truck Wreck Cliebt

I want to express my sincere thanks to Darren, Kate and the rest of the Butler Tobin team for their hard work on my case. Initially before I spoke with Darren, I presumed that I would call the other diver’s insurance company and they’d agree to cover all my bills, as well as pay me for my totaled veh...icle, and the pains I was having. But when the insurance company’s adjuster called me and extended an offer very early on to pay some of my bills and told me that she would give me $1,000 for my pain, I was shocked. How could this adjuster be making an offer when she didn’t even have a full picture of my injuries or what my long-term medical treatment would be? I decided to consult with an attorney. I was referred to Darren from someone in my family. I watched his videos and researched him online. He fought for me and it was a lot more than I thought he would win for me. I am extremely pleased with the result of my case.

Posted by Courtney | May 19, 2015

Highly Recommended - Knowledgeable, Experienced, and Excellent Negotiator

Darren Tobin and his firm were highly recommended to me by several attorneys at my law firm in Midtown. When I called Darren to discuss my case, he spent a great deal of time on the phone with me going over the details and pointing out the strengths and weaknesses as he saw them. As an attorney mysel...f, I recognized the difficulties with my case and knew it would be an uphill battle. I appreciated Darren's candidness and sincerity with me. From that first phone conversation, I trusted him entirely. He started work immediately on my case, checked in with me frequently to provide updates, did an excellent job negotiating with opposing counsel and reading between the lines, and exceeded all my expectations regarding the outcome. He took a difficult case, put in more work than we both expected was necessary, responded to any question or concern I had promptly, was friendly and easy to talk to, and made me feel like I was his only client and his biggest priority although I know he is very busy. Darren is an extremely knowledgeable and experienced personal injury attorney and having now been represented by him, I understand why he came so highly recommended to me.

Posted by anonymous | May 07, 2015

Great practice that delivered results!

Butler Tobin was great to work with and after leaving another practice helped restore my faith in PI attorneys. They were informed, helpful and deliver results in no time at all. After suffering a hit and run, I didn't want to deal with much more nonsense from a lawyer - they were straightforward- I ...always spoke with an attorney and not a paralegal. It was a great experience and I would recommend them to anyone!

Posted by Samantha | April 30, 2015

Darren Tobin is the best lawyer!

Darren Tobin is the best lawyer! If you want results, he is the man to get the job done. I was involved in a DUI motor vehicle accident in November 2013. I was a bit skeptical about getting a lawyer. After a week of research and explaining in details how the accident occurred, I was drained and of ...course I was convinced that the reviews I was reading may have been done by workers or friends but after a formal meeting with Darren, I was sure that he was the guy for the job. From the very beginning, Darren has explained every part of the process and answered every question I had. He made me feel very comfortable and secure. He will communicate with you directly every time you contact him. He explained the way things worked in details (insurance and in court) and provided many estimates with scenarios of how the case may go and what the plans were moving forward if the case went in either direction. The result that we finally earned was about 20 times more than what Geico Insurance company was offering! If you are still skeptical about choosing Darren as your lawyer, do the research for yourself. I will send anyone who needs an honest, hard-working and friendly lawyer to Darren and his team at Butler Tobin. Thanks again Darren!!

Posted by James | April 30, 2015

great lawyers

Darren Tobin was my first choice and by far the best choice! I was a victim in a car accident and went with Darren at the advice of my girlfriend’s dad. He met with me in person over coffee and gave me his cell phone number the minute we met. We texted frequently and emailed often. Darren Tobin mad...e me feel like I was his #1 client. He was available, and was willing to answer any questions I had. I had never been a client of a lawyer before, but this was a great first experience. Darren listened to my concerns, and sincerely did what I wanted. He is friendly and personable. He also knows the law and tracked down a witness that even the police didn’t know about! So he (1) listened to me; (2) tracked down a witness that even the police couldn’t find; (3) beat the insurance company’s offers; (4) won the case on the legal merits; (5) and did it all with a smile on his face. Darren, I thank you.

See All Client Reviews