Skip to main content

About me

Mr. Reynolds is the founder of the firm and concentrates his area of practice in  criminal law, in both federal and state courts. He is an experienced trial attorney who has handled thousands of cases in both state and federal courts. He has a reputation as an aggressive and persuasive advocate for his clients.


Mr. Reynolds is a Certified Death Penalty Attorney for Pennsylvania.


Mr. Reynolds is a former prosecutor, having worked for over seven years as an Assistant District Attorney in both the Montgomery and Delaware County District Attorney’s Offices.  During his career as a prosecutor, Mr. Reynolds prosecuted a number of high profile murder, sexual assault, drug trafficking and gambling cases. As such, he is extremely qualified to represent you in any criminal matter you have pending, whether complex or not, in both state and federal courts.


Mr. Reynolds was previously appointed as a Special Assistant United States Attorney, where he prosecuted violent offenders and drug traffickers in federal court. He is experienced in the federal criminal process from pre-indictment investigations (Federal Grand Jury) and indictment through to all trial matters. Mr. Reynolds has the experience to represent you effectively in any federal criminal matter whether it is during the investigation process or post-arrest.


 Mr. Reynolds is uniquely qualified to assist you during any investigation that may be ongoing. For over two years, Mr. Reynolds was the supervising attorney in charge the Investigating Grand Jury.  In that position, he worked hand-in-hand with law enforcement and other prosecutors from the initial investigation through to the conclusion of matters ranging from murder and narcotics cases to complex white color and gambling offenses. During this time, he also conducted several “Wire-Tap” investigations. Mr. Reynolds’   experience and knowledge of the inner workings of the Grand Jury and the “Wire-Tap” Act serves his clients well, whether they are the target of an investigation or merely a witness, because he is able to achieve the best possible pre-charge outcome for his clients.


 Mr. Reynolds has lectured before the Delaware County Board of Judges, has taught legal education classes for the Pennsylvania District Attorney’s Association and has lectured police officers and prosecutors on topics such as probable cause, investigative techniques and the Grand Jury. He has also taught both prosecutors and students on trial advocacy techniques.


 Mr. Reynolds is a Temple University graduate and received his Juris Doctorate from Temple University School of Law in 2001, evening division.




Photos and videos

544257 1378742563

Practice areas


  1. Criminal Defense: 75%
  2. Federal Crime: 25%



Fixed (sometimes), Free consultation (30 minutes)

Payment types:

Cash, Check, Credit card

Attorney endorsements

15 total 

Are you an attorney? Endorse this lawyer

  • Daniel Joseph Donohue

    I endorse this lawyer.


    Daniel Donohue Criminal defense Attorney
    Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

  • Louis Anthony Mincarelli

    I endorse this lawyer. I have know Coley for some time now and have worked on multiple cases with him. He has always demonstrated a wealth of knowledge of the law and has shown that he is fearless in the courtroom. He often gets results that I am confident lesser attorneys would only dream about.


    Louis Mincarelli Criminal defense Attorney
    Relationship: Worked together on matter

Contact info

Reynolds Firm, LLC

1515 Market street
Suite 1210
Philadelphia, PA, 19102

Reynolds Firm, LLC

21 West Third Street
Media, PA, 19063



We have not found any instances of professional misconduct for this lawyer.
Avvo contributions
Legal answers
Award nameGrantorDate granted
Top 100 Trial LawyersNational Trial Lawyers2014
Distinguished Performance - Trial Advocacy IITemple University School Of LawN/A
Outstanding Oral AdvocacyTemple University School of LawN/A
Excellence in Trial AdvocacyTemple University School of LawN/A
Work experience
TitleCompany nameDuration
Managing PartnerReynolds Firm, LLC2013 - Present
FounderLaw Offices of Coley O'Brien Reynolds2009 - 2013
AttorneyMandracchia and McWhirk, LLC2009 - 2009
Assistant District AttorneyMontgomery County District Attorney's Office2005 - 2009
Special Assistant United States AttorneyUnited States Attorney's Office - Philadelphia2003 - 2007
Assistant District AttorneyDelaware County District Attorney's Office2001 - 2005
Law ClerkUnited States Attorney's Office - Philadelphia1998 - 2001
Law ClerkPhiladelphia District Attorney's Office1995 - 1998
Association namePosition nameDuration
National Trial Lawyers AssociationMember - Top 100 Lawyers2014 - Present
Philadelphia Bar AssociationMember2014 - Present
Delaware County Bar AssociationMember2011 - Present
Pennsylvania Association of Criminal Defense LawyersMember2010 - Present
American Inns of CourtMaster2009 - Present
Pennsylvania Bar AssociationMember2002 - Present
Montgomery Bar AssociationMember2009 - 2010
Pennsylvania District Attorneys AssociationMember2001 - 2009
Legal cases
Case nameOutcome
Com. v. Covert (Philadelphia)EARLY PAROLE GRANTED
See all legal cases 
Publication nameTitleDate
School nameMajorDegreeGraduated
Temple University - James E. Beasley School of LawLawJD - Juris Doctor2001
Temple UniversityEnglishBA - Bachelor of Arts1996
Speaking engagements
Conference nameTitleDate
Summer Intern ProgramInvestigative Grand JuryN/A
Investigative TechniquesProbable CauseN/A
Bench BarPower Point in the Court RoomN/A