Virgina Workers' Compensation Treating Physician Rule is Alive and Well

Posted over 2 years ago. Applies to Virginia, 41 helpful votes

Email

In a recent case, the Full Commission of the Virginia Workers’ Compensation Commission had to decide whether or not to uphold the ‘treating physician" rule. Simply stated, the rule says if all other matters are equal the Commission gives greater weight to the opinion of a treating physician than that of an independent medical examiner.

The case was Walker v. Manorcare Health Services, VA0000018701 (April 18, 2012 Opinion). Walker had filed a claim for benefits for an October 8, 2008 lower back injury. She treated with a physician and a nurse practitioner over a number of months. The nurse practitioner consistently related the treatment to the October 8, 2008 accident. The insurer referred the claimant for an independent medical examination with Dr. Gordon. He opined Walker may have had a back strain on October 8, 2011 but she should have recovered from this and her ongoing treatment and disability was no longer related to the October 8, 2008 accident. Dr. Gordon advised any current back problems were caused by Walker’s pre-existing back condition.

The deputy commissioner who heard the case awarded Walker benefits giving greater weight to the opinion of the nurse practitioner.

The Full Commission (the three Commissioners who hear appeals) agreed with the deputy commissioner and gave greater weight to the opinion of the nurse practitioner. A dissenting Commissioner disagreed arguing that Dr. Gordon’s opinion on causation should have been decisive because it was supported by objective findings of a pre-existing condition in 2006.

The majority opinion did acknowledge the history of the 2006 back problem but noted it did not keep her out of work but the October 8, 2008 accident did keep her out of work. Due to this additional factor, the majority accepted the opinion of the Nurse Practitioner over that of Dr. Gordon, the independent medical examiner.

Additional Resources

You can contact Jerry Lutkenhaus for a free consultation on a Virginia Workers' Compensation claim by phone 804-358-4766.

Virginia Workers' Compensation Lawyer

Richmond Virginia Workers' Compensation Lawyer

Rate this guide

Related Topics

Types of personal injuries

There are many types of personal injuries for which financial damages can be awarded, including physical, emotional, and psychological injuries.

Work-related personal injuries

Employees can sue for damages if they’ve suffered work-related injuries. These lawsuits are separate from workers’ compensation and cover more kinds of injury.

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask a Lawyer

Get free answers from experienced attorneys.

 

Ask now

29,040 answers this week

3,449 attorneys answering