Even if you have time to think about them, most states will let employers get away with making you sign away rights you thought were guaranteed in the constitution. If an employer presents you with an arbitration agreement or waiver of your right to trial pre-employment or during your employment, that's the time to negotiate to make it go away. If the employer won't negotiate, you can accept it or turn down the job. If they present it to you after you've accepted the job, most states will let them say, "sign it or be fired."
Courts love arbitration agreements. It lightens their workload. Don't expect help from the courts anytime soon. The remedy will have to be through Congress or your state legislature.
Here's what you need to know about arbitration.
What is arbitration?An arbitration is when you submit your employment dispute to a neutral third party instead of the courts. Some arbitration is non-binding, that is, the parties can still go to court if they aren't satisfied with the decision. But most arbitration is binding on the parties. That means you don't even get to appeal an arbitrator's decision under most circumstances.
ArbitratorsAn arbitrator who handles employment arbitrations is usually a current or former employment lawyer, HR person, or other individual with experience in employment law matters. Arbitrators go through training on the process before they are approved to be on a panel. Depending on your arbitration agreement, you may have one or three arbitrators on your panel. You will usually have some input into the choice of your arbitrator. You will always be able to seek to remove them if they have a conflict of interest.
RulesMost arbitration forums have detailed rules you need to follow throughout the process. Try to elect a forum, if you have a choice, that has employment rules (a great example is American Arbitration Association, which has separate rules for employment disputes), not just general commercial rules. Employment rules usually have some built-in due process protocols to protect individuals. Commercial rules are more geared toward businesses, and may assume the businesses are represented and experienced in arbitrations.
DiscoveryUsually, arbitration relies on mutual exchange of documents, no depositions, and no full discovery that you'd get in courts. However, in employment situations, many arbitrators will allow limited discovery and depositions. It's important to understand what will be allowed from the start of your process.
CostsWho bears the costs is decided in the arbitration agreement or, if the agreement is silent, in the rules of the arbitration forum. If the rules require the employer and employee to split costs equally from the beginning, that's a huge advantage for the employer. Remember, arbitrators have to be paid for their time. Most employees, especially unemployed ones, can't afford to pay. The better way is to have the employer bear the costs from the beginning, then if the employee loses have them assessed with all or some of those costs at the end. But if your employer chose the forum and wrote the agreement, can you guess which way they'll likely choose? If you have a lawyer representing you, they may be able to fight to get a fair apportionment of costs.
TimeThe good news is, arbitration is usually quicker than a court case. The bad news is that there may be shortened deadlines for filing. Read your agreement and the rules very carefully.
- Arbitration has lots to offer as a form of alternate dispute resolution. It can save time and money, and the person making the decision is experienced in employment law. If there are due process protocols in place and a fair cost allocation, arbitration is nothing to fear.
- Just because a proposed arbitrator handles primarily employer-side law, doesn't mean they'll be bad on your case. Most arbitrators take their position as neutrals very seriously. I'm an arbitrator who also happens to be a lawyer representing primarily employees, and I've ruled for management in some of my arbitrations. Go for experience, a balanced resume, and if you can, look at some prior decisions before you make a decision on which arbitrators to strike from your panel.
- Sometimes both sides hate the arbitrator choices the forum offers. Both sides can agree on an arbitrator they like outside the agreed forum.
- Most objections you hear in court won't apply to arbitration. Arbitrators can hear irrelevant evidence and all sorts of evidence and testimony that would be inadmissible in court. They tend to err on the side of allowing more, rather than less, information.
- You don't have to be represented in arbitration any more than you have to be represented in court. Still, if you can find a lawyer who handles employment arbitrations you're better off than going it alone in most cases.