Why do attorneys advise against being a confidential informant but this type of things exist all the time?

Asked almost 2 years ago - Stockton, CA

Does the DA and police really screw ppl over by enticing them to tell on others even when a counsel is involved?

Attorney answers (4)

  1. Seth Andrew Weinstein

    Contributor Level 15


    Lawyers agree

    Answered . Attorneys advise against being a Confidential Informant because 1) it can be dangerous to the CI 2) a lot of what CIs say is incorrect just to get them exonerated 3) the government can find something wrong with your work as a CI and invalidate the plea agreement.

    Seth Weinstein, Esq.
    Practicing throughout Southern California
    (310) 707-7131

    This reply should NOT be considered a legal opinion of your case / inquiry. At this time I do not have sufficient... more
  2. Jack Richard Lebowitz


    Contributor Level 18


    Lawyers agree


    Answered . Confidential informants do two things: (1) inform on their friends and family's possibly criminal activities and throw them under the bus to save their own skins, or (2) play amateur vice squad officers doing dangerous things like trying to buy or sell drugs or guns to suspected criminals in "sting" operations while wearing a wire.

    Even if the police tell you they will keep your identity secret, your friends may suspect that you "dropped a dime" on them if they are busted and you miraculously walk.

    Or, if you're playing amateur "Dick Tracy" you can walk into the lion's den and wind up dead.

    See this article "The Throwaways" by Sarah Stillman about a 23 year old woman busted for pot in Florida who agreed to be a CI to get off the charges and wound up dead in a botched gun sale sting.

    So the short answer: is being a CI to save your own skin better than losing your friends, life and integrity or should you just man up and take some other plea bargain or trial that doesn't compromise your integrity? And if it does result in just a reduction of charges and you're going to serve jail or prison time anyway, be aware that "snitches" and "rats" compete with child molesters as the most despised class of inmates and it may very well get out and you will need to be isolated in protective custody if you're lucky or end up with a shank in your back in the yard if you're not.

    I don't think having a counsel involved changes anything, except that usually the police try to make the deal before the arrest and retaining counsel so there's not an issue with someone being busted and then their friends wisely avoid them. I don't think counsel typically encourage their clients to become informants, but I don't know....I'm only stating my own views here....

    This answer is provided under the Avvo.com “Terms and Conditions of Use” (“ToU”), particularly ¶9 which states... more
  3. Joseph Salvatore Farina

    Contributor Level 17


    Lawyers agree

    Answered . This is a tough question to answer and many criminal defense attorneys are bitterly split on whether to represent a person who becomes a confidential informant. Some won't do it for the reasons outlined by others in this post and truly believe that CI's are the lowest form of human beings who are just trying to save their bacon. The CI exposes themselves to all kinds of dangers in county jail and state prisons and is they reason they are usually kept in protective custody or administrative segregation. And there have been many instances where CI's have lied just to get a lighter sentence or some other benefit from the government. If a CI is cooperating with the cops and DA's and sign some kind of written agreement, defense counsel has to be told and will get a copy of the agreement. Then the CI will be aggressively cross-examined by the defense attorney at trial on their cooperation with the police and DA. A DA will use every trick in the book to get a conviction, even if that means turning to a CI to get at the bigger fish.

  4. Brian K Wanerman

    Contributor Level 18


    Lawyers agree

    Answered . Police and prosecutors lie to defendants all the time to get them to confess to something they didn't do, make incriminating statements, or take a plea deal that's much harsher than they really need to take. Why would you trust them when the tell you that they'll give you lenient treatment if you'll agree to do their dirty work for them?

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask a Lawyer

Get free answers from experienced attorneys.


Ask now

25,322 answers this week

2,965 attorneys answering

Ask a Lawyer

Get answers from top-rated lawyers.

  • It's FREE
  • It's easy
  • It's anonymous

25,322 answers this week

2,965 attorneys answering