Asked over 1 year ago - Santa Cruz, CAFlag
I've heard it's more accurate, but could refusing a breath test makes things harder for me?
Don't speak legalese? We define thousands of terms in plain English.Browse our legal dictionary
You can refuse the preliminary alcohol screening device that they give you at the scene, but you cannot refuse to take a blood or breath test. If you do, it's disasterous for your license and can actually add time to a DUI sentence (assuming you're found guilty in the end). Each has it's pros and cons for both sides, but neither is necessarily "better" than the other.
I advise refusing the PAS test on the scene, because that is optional and will only be used against you. I would then advise choosing a breath test, because breath tests are less reliable and easier to attack. If you can cause a whole lot of time to elapse in the meanwhile, such as by asking for a blood test and then changing your mind and switching to a breath test when they take you to the hospital for a blood draw, you will have created more opportunity for your defense. But, the best option of all to beat a DUI, is to not drink and drive.
Your question is one which attorneys debate all the time. Some think you should take the breath test because the machine is open to attack. On the other hand, the machine is open to attack is because it is error ridden. You don't want to blow into a machine and have it read .09 - when your BAC was actually lower. In that scenario it would be better to take the blood test.
You can also attack the blood test such as the methods of storage, blood draw, etc. Sometimes the DA forgets about calling the correct witnesses to trial to lay the foundation for the blood. Sometimes the blood gets lost. I know of a case where the blood was retested and it had another persons name on the vile and not the defendants.
Now back to your question. I do not know which is better. Both have their strengths and weaknesses.
The question you need to ask yourself, what is in my system? If you only have alcohol in your system, a blood test is more accurate and the blood can be retested for your Blood Alcohol Level, your Blood Type, and the amount of preservative in the blood container. (Very important...)
If there's any other substance in your system, such as marijuana or prescription medication, the prosecutor can retest the blood sample for everything in your blood.
If more than alcohol is found in your system, it makes the case much more difficult to fight in the criminal court. As for the DMV, you would need to call my office.
26,433 answers this week
2,679 professionals answering