My boyfriend is on probation he only been on it for a year now and he has never got in trouble while on probation. He is now in jail for possession of a fire arm and he is trying to see if he can get a ATR but his probation officer told him that he does not qualify for one because he has violent charge. Is this true or do they have to offer you an alternative if you never had one?
Criminal Defense Attorney
No, agents are not required to offer Alternatives to Revocation. Agents go through what's called a "Plotkin analysis" (named after the Plotkin case in Wisconsin) that looks at the needs and likelihood of controlling the behavior, correcting the behavior, and not depreciating the seriousness of the violation. They then need to discuss all alternatives considered and explain their rejection, including amendment of his Rules of Community Supervision, Placement in an alternative group home (i.e., a halfway house), Electronic Monitoring, any institutional and community ATRs, and simple warnings.
Having an attorney can help negotiate an ATR, but if he was picked up on a felony -- particularly a Felon In Possession of a Firearm, which implies that he had a past felony in the first place -- after only a year on probation I'd say it's highly unlikely he's going to get an ATR. Not to put too fine a point on it, but unless he can show the gun wasn't his it's going to be pretty hard to justify an ATR by arguing something like "I didn't realize having a gun as a felon would be a violation."
I agree with Attorney Golden's analysis. There are certain times when ATRs are appropriate and other times when they are arguably not appropriate. The analysis is highly fact-specific. He should get the best attorney he can afford, both to fight the new case and argue the revocation.
ALWAYS mark answers you appreciate with positive feedback and select a best answer!<p><a href="http://msm-law.com/attorney-nicholas-j-passe"> Attorney Nicholas J. Passe</a><p>Disclaimer: Per the avvo.com community guidelines, no attorney/client relationship is created by the asking or answering of questions on this web site, nor do the answers constitute legal advice. Always hire an attorney before making any important legal decisions. Posting details of a case on avvo.com may be subject to discovery in criminal or civil litigation, so erring on the side of nondisclosure is wise.<p><a href="http://www.msm-law.com">Moen Sheehan Meyer, Ltd.</a>