What do I do when a collection agency comes after me for a satisfied debt?

About 6 years ago, I paid off a judgement against me. I have the proof that it is a satisfied judgement, and now I just received a new collection notice for the same debt from the original creditor. The statute of limitations is up, and duly noted on the paper as well. What are my options in contacting this company, without getting myself wrapped up in re-payment of a debt from a credit card from 11-2000?

Hicksville, NY -

Attorney Answers (4)

Dorothy G Bunce

Dorothy G Bunce

Bankruptcy Attorney - Las Vegas, NV
Answered

I would suggest that you respond in writing to state that the debt was paid and ask that the creditor correct their records as well as your credit report. Mistakes happen all the time & I have always found that you catch more flies with honey than you do with vinegar.

Hope this perspective helps!

Mark as helpful
Michael J Corbin

Michael J Corbin

Bankruptcy Attorney - Faribault, MN
Answered

There is nothing for you to do - they know they can't sue you for the money, so don't deal with the collection agency at all. Contact all the credit reporting agencies and make sure it is either off your report entirely or being reported as paid.

We can be reached at 507.334.0155. Our web address is: www. corbin-law-office.com. Answers on Avvo are not to... more
Mark as helpful
Michael John Sheridan

Michael John Sheridan

Bankruptcy Attorney - Bloomington, MN
Answered

Respond to the letter with a copy of the complaint (or other court document showing the case number is regarding the particular account number with that creditor). Also include a copy of the satisfaction of judgment. In your letter politely point out that a mistake has been made as you already resolved the debt.

Keep a copy of the letter. If they continue their collection efforts, contact your state's Attorney General office.

Mark as helpful
Lisa Kaye Deselms Dent

Lisa Kaye Deselms Dent

Estate Planning Attorney - Paris, IL
Answered

You can certainly send proof. Also keep a diary of all calls made to you. (Date, time, name of caller, and what is said.) If they persist, look for an attorney knowledgeable in fair debt matters.

This response is based on the limited facts presented and is not intended to substitute for direct legal advice,... more
Mark as helpful

Questions? An attorney can help.

Ask your questions on our Q&A forum. It's free and anonymous.

Ask a Lawyer

Need to find an attorney? Browse our lawyer directory.

Find a Lawyer