Unconscionable: effective arguments in Landlord Tenant dispute?

Asked over 2 years ago - Las Vegas, NV

There appear several issues with the lease. It states a requirement by the tenant to pay landlord's attorney fees; we are additionally being assessed late fees for rent paid two to four days late yet, lease states late fees apply after 10 days; Landlord failed to make repairs to plumbing; changed items in lease without written notice. Landlord refused to auth issuance of building fob until rent was paid without a proceeding; we received 3 reconciled statements all of which differ and each contain accounting errors, it contained a 1k elect bill we'd never seen that turns out to be an error also. Are these not issues that would encourage the court to vacate an eviction (in addition to inaccurate billings) and are these not unconscionable errors intended to harass?

Attorney answers (3)

  1. Scott E. Chapman

    Contributor Level 10

    1

    Best Answer
    chosen by asker

    Answered . All of the things you have listed are breaches of the lease, including your failure to pay rent. If you have gone past 10 days? You did not say. However, when a landlord breaches a lease, you still have to pay rent if you want to live there. You can go to court and request the court order the fix; you can leave the property and claim that the landlord would not fix the property; you can make requests that these items be fixed. However, the landlord can withhold new keys if rent is not paid. The landlord MUST provide the new property manager's information.

    The things you are discussing appear to be 'defenses' to eviction proceedings. IF YOU ARE PAYING RENT, you can bring these issues up. You cannot fix things and take it out of your rent, unless the agreement says so. You cannot pay late and expect to stay in the home, unless the agreement says you have a 10 day grace period, which it looks like it does.

    Unconscionable (legal definitiion in a landlord tenant context): Something that is so unreasonably detrimental to the interest of the tenant as to render the lease unenforceable. (The UCC has a basic test which states ""in the light of the general commercial background and the commercial needs of the particular trade or case, the clauses involved are so one-sided as to be unconscionable under the circumstances.")

    However, in your case a water leak with standing water is not just unconscionable it makes the home untenable. You are not really wanting to look at unconscionable, but untenable, if you are trying to get out of the lease. Certainly the landlord must come fix the pipes, unless the lease says otherwise, or if you caused the leak.

    As you can see, it depends on what your objective is to determine what advice you need here. If your question is about eviction, just pay your rent. That cures the issue. If your landlord if not fixing things, you need to take him to court.

    The recommendations in this answer are not considered legal advice for the purposes of ethical evaluation, nor do... more
  2. Matthew T. Cecil

    Contributor Level 12

    Answered . Yes, it seems that the issues create a legal defense which would stop a summary eviction. However, the "accounting errors" cannot be both simple errors and evidence of the intent to harass. They are either evidence of incompetence or negligence, or they are evidence of harassment.

    Is there a provision in the lease that allows who ever prevails to recover attorney fees, or does the lease only allow the landlord to collect fees? Generally, a one-sided fee provision is not enforceable.

    I hope this has helped. Good luck.

    I am licensed to practice in Nevada. Please note - the information I post is not legal advice and my response... more
  3. Brian Coleman Kelly

    Contributor Level 14

    Answered . The best way to stay eviction is to pay rent.

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask a Lawyer

Get free answers from experienced attorneys.

 

Ask now

22,515 answers this week

2,911 attorneys answering

Ask a Lawyer

Get answers from top-rated lawyers.

  • It's FREE
  • It's easy
  • It's anonymous

22,515 answers this week

2,911 attorneys answering