Two brothers falsely accused of arson with no evidence against them

Asked almost 2 years ago - Camden, MI

I am a friend of the parents of Bob & John Bennett who are to be sentenced 03 - 25 - 13 for several arson fires in the village of Camden , Michigan . No evidence has been found against these boys but justice is being swayed . Authorities brought in tracking dogs , with the boys standing in the open , & the dogs picked up no scent of the boys . Regardless they are still being charge & face up to 10 years in prison . There attorney has been Ronda Eves of Goldwater , Michigan . My goal is to bring this to everyone's attention I can for help . Your suggestions would be appreciated . Thank you

Attorney answers (3)

  1. Timothy J. Klisz


    Contributor Level 18


    Lawyer agrees

    Best Answer
    chosen by asker

    Answered . If they are sentenced, then they plead guilty, no contest or found guilty by a judge or jury. I'm sure their attorney will do their best job.

    My answer to you question does not constitute legal advice. Only an in person or telephone consultation will... more
  2. Becket J. Jones


    Contributor Level 15


    Lawyers agree

    Answered . HILLSDALE — All three of the suspects accused of burning numerous buildings last summer pleaded guilty in Hillsdale County Circuit Court Monday.
    Jason Walston, 34, Robert Bennett Jr., 18, and John Bennett, 23, each pleaded guilty to arson of real estate property as part of a plea deal and each faces up to 10 years in prison.
    John Bennett pleaded guilty to two counts of arson of real estate property, while the others only face one count. All three men had a charge of arson of a dwelling or house dropped as part of the deal. That charge would have carried a maximum sentence of 20 years in prison.
    John confessed to starting a barn on fire at 147 North Main St. in Camden on Ju­ly 30 and Robert admitted to starting a house fire at 121 Jasper St. in Cam­den on Aug. 13, according to court documents. Walston has admitted to burning the house on 205 North Main St. in Camden. No one was in the homes at the times of the fires.
    The men will be sentenced on March 25 at 8:30 a.m. - See more at:

    Above is what I found online. Assuming the plea taking process was properly done by the Court, all three defendants plead guilty and stated on the record that they were not threatened or induced into their pleas. Thus, while some in the community may not be convinced, the defendants themselves have admitted guilt in open court.

    From this point on, the only issue is sentencing (unless they were threatened or induced into a false plea). If Bob and John have limited or no criminal histories, then their sentences may end up being lighter than you might currently expect.

    In terms of suggestions, all I can really say is cross your fingers on the day of sentencing.

    Best of luck to both of them at sentencing and in the future.

    An Attorney-Client relationship has not been established. Becket J. Jones is not your attorney.
  3. Jonathan Neal Portner


    Contributor Level 14


    Lawyers agree

    Answered . They are represented by defense counsel and it appears since they are being sentenced, they are pleading guilty. They of course should not have the same attorney for starters. In a criminal case this poses a potential conflict. Discovery in the case must be reviewed. My hunch is it will reveal some real evidence pointing to the boys.

    Jonathan N. Portner, Esquire, Portner & Shure, P.A. Maryland and Virginia Personal Injury Attorneys. This... more

Related Topics

Criminal charges for arson

Arson is setting fire, with malicious intent and without authorization from the property owner or manager, to buildings, land, vehicles, or other property.

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask a Lawyer

Get free answers from experienced attorneys.


Ask now

22,670 answers this week

2,760 attorneys answering

Ask a Lawyer

Get answers from top-rated lawyers.

  • It's FREE
  • It's easy
  • It's anonymous

22,670 answers this week

2,760 attorneys answering