took out a $2,000 personal line of credit in 1999 with my credit union. Payments on the loan were deducted automatically from my bank account. By 2003 my bank statements were showing 0.00 and available line of credit as $2,000 indicating the loan was paid in full.
In October of 2009 some bill collection agency calls me saying they are collecting a debt on behalf of some company I never heard of. Saying it was a personal line of credit and the debt was $3000!!
I sent the 'prove it letters" to the collection agency demanding they prove I owe on this loan and their right to collect. All they sent me was the original note I signed for the personal loan back in 1999. I have a bank statement showing the loan back at 0 balance in 2003. The bill collectors are threatening suit. Statute?
Yes, it sounds like you have a good SOL defense, but better than that, you paid the debt. Send the debt collector a certified letter noting that's been 7 years since you paid this debt off, with a copy of your bank statement and advise them that if they contact you any more, you'll sue THEM for violation of state and federal debt collection laws.
Please see this question and answer, and the one lined within it.
Disclaimer: Please note that this answer does not constitute legal advice, and should not be relied on, since each state has different laws, each situation is fact specific, and it is impossible to evaluate a legal problem without a comprehensive consultation and review of all the facts and documents at issue. This answer does not create an attorney-client relationship.
Lawsuit / Dispute Attorney
I am not sure what letter you sent to the debt collector, but the facts you describe are a classic dispute that Congress had contemplated when it approved the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act. If you have a document that shows you paid off the debt, I would copy that and send it with my sample letter 1.1 as soon as possible and explain that the debt was paid in full in 2003. I would also request any documents that show any charges to the account after your $0 statement date.
Your facts do not indicate if the account was closed, after you paid it off. What if someone accessed the account and charged on it several thousand dollars? You need to get more information on this, because you may be the victim of identity theft. The second link below is to my Legal Guide for victims of identity theft, which may also help with your research of this account that you can prove was $0 in 2003.
Until we know when these charges occurred and when the account was considered in default, it is premature to determine if the debt is older than the statute of limitations, which for a California credit union, would probably be four years from date of default.