Should my grandson take a polygraph to determine if he is a witness to a homicide? He will be 18 on the 15th

Asked 6 months ago - Indianapolis, IN

He told a friend at school that he saw a man get shot and killed. When police were told he was called in to answer questions and he told detective he didn't witness the shooting he was just there later. He said that he told the other student he saw it because he thought it was "cool". He has a history of ADHD/Bipolar disorder and has a history of doing and saying things to get attention. The detective has now been scheduled for a polygraph test.

Attorney answers (4)

  1. John Douglas Razumich

    Contributor Level 13
    Best Answer
    chosen by asker

    Answered . Nothing good can come from his speaking with the detective, especially if he is going to be hooked up to a polygraph.

    Polygraph examinations are inadmissible as evidence in criminal prosecutions, but police officers frequently use them as tools to force confessions and admissions (which are admissible in court) out of suspects. I am not familiar with detectives hooking a non-suspect up to a polygraph. Be very cautious.

  2. Bradley Lynn Banks


    Contributor Level 10


    Lawyer agrees


    Answered . The use of polygraphs has been found to be unreliable in many respects. Not sure why they would be giving polygraph to a possible witness. I'd be reluctant to allow him to participate in the polygraph as they many be seeking answers to questions other than what it may appear on its face. You very well may want to speak with counsel before engaging in further contact with the detective.

    Answers provided here are for information purposes only and not intended to replace speaking with an attorney.... more
  3. Elizabeth Cameron Milliken

    Contributor Level 6

    Answered . The detective may believe your son has information that could be of use to the murder investigation but may want to determine your son's credibility before relying upon his statements. Nonetheless, your son could also be a suspect, or his statements could implicate him in part or all of the crime without him realizing it. Your son cannot be required to submit to the polygraph, but it would be best for him to consult with an attorney before talking with the detective any further. His attorney can act as a "go between" with the detective to determine if your son is considered a possible suspect or just a witness.

  4. Cynthia Judith Hernandez

    Contributor Level 5

    Answered . Usually the scheduling of a polygraph means that a person is "of interest" and a potential suspect in an investigation. Do not attend the polygraph alone. Hire counsel immediately to provide a buffer between law enforcement and your son. They will press and say lots of things to the unrepresented to lull them into thinking that there are not a suspect. Don't fall for it. Lawyer up.

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask a Lawyer

Get free answers from experienced attorneys.


Ask now

28,392 answers this week

3,082 attorneys answering

Ask a Lawyer

Get answers from top-rated lawyers.

  • It's FREE
  • It's easy
  • It's anonymous

28,392 answers this week

3,082 attorneys answering