Self directed Schwab account - fiduciary fraud?

Asked over 2 years ago - San Francisco, CA

I just found out a family member who owned stocks held at Schwab opened a money market and was writing checks versus his securities. He is a complete novice and has little knowledge of securities or of financing. Schwab has been charging him $1400/ month on margin interest. Over the last 10 years.. it's about 140,000 just in interest. He has always had enough stock to liquidate and pay out what he was taking out, but was verbally informed that he could not do that. As a result, he just allowed schwab to continue to charge him. this is a self directed account. Does schwab have a fiduciary responsibility in a self directed account? I believe this is taking advantage of someone who does not about financing.

so now he has 300k in stocks but is short 200k cash in money market fund.

Attorney answers (3)

  1. Robert V Cornish Jr.

    Contributor Level 16


    Lawyers agree

    Answered . The margin interest being charged actually appears reasonable. The question becomes is whether your family member was suitable for margin in the first place. Someone needs to sign a margin agreement to have a margin account. This in most cases requires attestations about one's investment objectives and financial situation. Someone approved the margin agreement and you should try to find out why.

    Whether there is a fiduciary duty here is questionable in my view. It's sort of a dram shop kind of thing. But again, I think the clue to what's going on resides in the margin agreement. At the very least, take a look at it.

    The foregoing is not legal advice nor is it in any manner whatsoever meant to create or impute an attorney/client... more
  2. Daniel Mcleod Carlson


    Contributor Level 8


    Lawyer agrees

    Answered . You family member may have a claim agaisnt Schwab. If they gave him incorrect information about reducing his margin account they are liable for damages, and of course, why would they do that? Margin agreements are very profitable for brokerages.

    Margin agreements usually have attorney fee clauses in them, so if your family member has a claim and wins, he has a good chance of recovering his attorney fees as well.

    The precise facts are very important here, including dates, as Schwab will want to argue time limitations on some of this. Also, what State you are in plays a part.

    If your family member wishes to discuss this claim in more detail, I am happy to give a phone consultation. Feel free to contact me.

    Legal Disclaimer: Mr. Carlson is licensed to practice law in California. The response herein is not legal advice... more
  3. Jon Martin Pettis

    Contributor Level 13

    Answered . Mr. Carlson's and mr. Cornish's answers were very good. See them for helP.

    Any comments offered are not intended as legal advice. This attorney does not know the specifics of the... more

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask a Lawyer

Get free answers from experienced attorneys.


Ask now

26,467 answers this week

2,789 attorneys answering

Ask a Lawyer

Get answers from top-rated lawyers.

  • It's FREE
  • It's easy
  • It's anonymous

26,467 answers this week

2,789 attorneys answering