Plea bargain charges verses charges presented at hearing

Asked over 1 year ago - Lancaster, CA

I need to understand how this work. I'm reading files public defender gave me.
Looking at hearing transcript, DA on last page of transcript asked judge to add an enhancement to the charges. They had an argument about it for the next page or so, at the end of which judge said he did not agree enhancement applied. But when I look at plea bargain, DA put it on there anyway. Defendant took the plea bargain despite the fact he was not guilty of that nor of another 4 charges on there. He was pressured into taking the deal because his brother was co-defendant and they told him unless he took the deal, his brother's deal would be withdrawn and brother would get LWOP. Is it normal/legal for DA to have added enhancement even though Judge said no in PH? How does work?

Additional information

NOTE #1 - I did not see in all the files that Public Defender handed me (they said that they gave me EVERYTHING they had) any other record of judge agreeing / adding this enhancement.

NOTE #2 - The judge who signed off on the plea bargain was not the same judge that presided at the Preliminary Hearing.

Can a DA put ANYTHING he wants on plea bargain or does the plea bargain charges have to match the charges the defendant was bound over with at PH? I believe they have the right to drop some charges, but do they have authority to add more without a judge consent?

Attorney answers (3)

  1. Michael Kevin Cernyar

    Pro

    Contributor Level 20

    3

    Lawyers agree

    Answered . It's not normal but does happen from time to time. Speak to an appellate attorney.

    The response above is not intended as legal advice since it’s impracticable to provide thorough, accurate advice... more
  2. Joseph Briscoe Dane

    Pro

    Contributor Level 20

    3

    Lawyers agree

    Answered . At preliminary hearing, the prosecution can request that the defendant be held to answer (ordered to stand trial) on any charges and enhancements they think they have proven. If the magistrate hearing the preliminary hearing agrees, they bind the defendant over on those charges and enhancements. The judge at prelim may not think there's enough evidence to support additional charges or enhancements and deny the request for a bind-over on those added charges/enhancements. The prosecution can file them in the new charging document (the "Information") anyway. The defense can then challenge whether there was in fact enough evidence through a motion pursuant to Penal Code section 995.

    If the enhancement was charged in the Information, it can properly be part of the plea bargain. If it was not filed, it can be added as part of a plea agreement, but the Information must be amended (either formally by filing a new document or by "interlineation" by requesting the court write it in). The defendant must be arraigned on the charges they are pleading guilty to. If the enhancement was not in the original Information, the judge should have arraigned the defendant (informed the defendant that the charge/enhancement was added) prior to taking the plea.

    That enhancement may have been added in exchange for dismissal of other charges, etc. Without reviewing the entire file, charging documents and transcript of the plea itself, it's tough to say exactly what happened. What I describe above is the general principle and the procedures involved.

    The above answer is for general information only and is based on the information you posted. Every case is fact... more
  3. Anthony Michael Solis

    Pro

    Contributor Level 20

    2

    Lawyers agree

    Answered . This does happen. that's what Penal Code Section 995 is for.

    No legal advice is given here. My responses to questions on Avvo are never intended as legal advice and must NOT... more

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask a Lawyer

Get free answers from experienced attorneys.

 

Ask now

28,023 answers this week

3,009 attorneys answering

Ask a Lawyer

Get answers from top-rated lawyers.

  • It's FREE
  • It's easy
  • It's anonymous

28,023 answers this week

3,009 attorneys answering