My husband is on state probation and was arrested for DWI . Can he use alcohol abuse as his defense and seek treatment not jail?

Asked almost 2 years ago - Austin, TX

He was given 8 years jail and 4 years probation for family violence assault, which he has a history of, due to drinking. He was in alcohol class, then put in a relapse class. He later caught his first DWI case. He truly has a drinking problem and is no criminal activity for almost 2 years. Can his court appointed lawyer request he be ordered to undergo treatment as opposed to revoking probation and serving jail time? If he must do jail time, is it likely that the judge will approve a weekend or other jail release program? Thanks in advance!

Attorney answers (5)

  1. Macy Michelle Jaggers

    Pro

    Contributor Level 20

    8

    Lawyers agree

    1

    Best Answer
    chosen by asker

    Answered . Your husband has two cases. A new (misdemeanor I assume) DWI and a probation violation on a felony assault. Typically this would be handled by first handling the DWI. If that case can be beaten, the pv may become a non-issue. However, the burden of proof on a probation violation is much lower than that for guilt or innocence at trial. And the felony court does not have to wait for the new case to be disposed of before having a revocation hearing on the pv. One attorney should be working both cases together to get him the most beneficial outcome overall. It sounds like he does need alcohol treatment and that his goal would be treatment over pen time. Of course his attorney can, and probably will, request in-patient treatment rather than pen time. Your husband may or may not want this result, however. I have had many clients reject the treatment offer because it can mean a year and a half in custody (for example, 3 months waiting for a bed, 12 months in safp, and 3 more months at a halfway house), only to be right back out on probation. It sounds like he's already on straight probation (since his exposure is limited to 8 years), so he doesn't have to worry about a conviction the way he would if he were on deferred. If his attorney works out a plea bargain agreement for 3 years TDC, he COULD be out in the same 18 months with none of the probation hassle to worry about. All that being said, we have several judges in Dallas now that will reject a TDC agreement and force the defendant into treatment. His attorney should be able to advise him of his options based on the facts as well as the DA's and judges involved. Of course, it certainly sounds like treatment is in his best interest, but the ultimate decision of which outcome to push the DA toward will be up to him.

    Macy Jaggers's answer to a legal question on Avvo does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Ms. Jaggers... more
  2. Jim Mitchell Medley

    Contributor Level 15

    7

    Lawyers agree

    4

    Answered . Are you comfortable with the court appointed lawyer? I would think not, considering you are on the internet looking for free tips from lawyers who don't know you or your husband. I would re-think the court-appointed lawyer and hire a lawyer who will work for you and answer your questions.

    I would focus first on defending the DWI charge. I'm sure simply drinking is a violation of his probation terms, so beating the DWI doesn't mean it all just goes away. But being convicted of a new criminal charge will make it worse on him. Plus, don't let the felony probation situation distract you from the fact that even a misdemeanor DWI conviction has its own long-term or even permanent consequences.

    Your husband certainly needs to put his best foot forward in terms of appearing sincere in asking for help, and owning up to the alcohol problem. A sincere plea for help is his best chance for getting some leniency from the judge. It is no guarantee though. I recommend you retain an attorney who will carefully work your husband and you through this process.

    Good luck.

  3. Stephen A. Gustitis

    Contributor Level 13

    7

    Lawyers agree

    Answered . I agree with the other lawyers suggesting you obtain the services of a lawyer who you trust. Whether it's a court-appointed lawyer (many of whom are excellent attorneys) or a lawyer you hire with your private funds. Furthermore, it's almost impossible for us to answer your question, without speculating. Only a qualified lawyer thoroughly familiar with the facts and law applicable to your husband's case can help him. That would be my focus . . . get a lawyer you trust and let them advise you.

  4. David N. Smith

    Contributor Level 14

    6

    Lawyers agree

    Answered . In this situation the judge has almost complete discretion to do what she thinks is best. Outpatient treatment is extremely unlikely. She might agree not to revoke his probation if he pleads to the new charge and goes into an intensive inpatient program as part of a second probation. A lot depends on his history of being employed, supporting his dependents, and having been otherwise law-abiding.

    This answer is intended to be taken as general information and not as specific legal advice. You should always... more
  5. Charles K. Kenyon Jr.

    Contributor Level 19

    4

    Lawyers agree

    Answered . His lawyer, whether court appointed or privately retained, can certainly argue for treatment as an alternative to revocation.
    Probation means you have already been convicted of a crime. A judge decided that you did not need to be imprisoned to protect society, but you are subject to being searched or locked up at any time if someone thinks that decision might have been wrong. You have one foot in the jail cell already!

    When talking to clients considering probation, I often compare it to being like moving back home with a step-parent who doesn’t like you. That step-parent gets to set your hours, tell you who your friends are, tell you where you can and cannot live, and talk to your boss at work. If he/she thinks you are breaking a rule, you can be put into jail until a decision is made. It is a significant change in your liberty.

    He needs to get clear on his probation rules and follow them to succeed at probation.


    If any answer on AVVO helps you, mine or someone else’s, please mark it as "helpful" or "best answer" to help AVVO know which answers to show others.

    Thank you.

    --- Experienced Criminal Defense Lawyer in Madison, Dane County, Wisconsin
    http://addbalance.com

    --- Facebook Page
    http://www.facebook.com/CriminalDefenseMadTown

    --- Talking to the Police - Advice from Lawyers and Police
    http://addbalance.com/police.htm

    --- Miranda Rights (and Wrongs)
    http://addbalance.com/miranda_rights.htm


    DISCLAIMER:

    Confidential information should not be disclosed in this Internet forum.

    I am an experienced Wisconsin criminal defense lawyer practicing in Madison (Dane County) Wisconsin. The laws in each jurisdiction can be very different. I cannot give legal advice over the Internet nor can I establish an attorney client relationship with you.

    If something I say disagrees with what your own lawyer is telling you, you should rely on your lawyer who is familiar with you, your entire case, the local courts and practices.

    Most questions are just better handled by an attorney familiar with the procedures of the courts in your area. Few, if any, legal matters should be handled via Internet communication. If you cannot afford an attorney, there should be agencies in your area that can provide discounted, or even free, legal services.

    This AVVO Answer is provided for general educational purposes only.

    Click on the “more” link below for more important information about this answer and AVVO.

    Confidential information should not be disclosed in this Internet forum. Click on the "More..." link for... more

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask a Lawyer

Get free answers from experienced attorneys.

 

Ask now

28,958 answers this week

3,119 attorneys answering

Ask a Lawyer

Get answers from top-rated lawyers.

  • It's FREE
  • It's easy
  • It's anonymous

28,958 answers this week

3,119 attorneys answering