Skip to main content

My friend is trying to make me pay for damages to her car and she has insurance, am I responsible for all damages?

Lagrange, GA |

My friend does not want to make an insurance claim because she has had multiple wrecks and she was notified the last time that the insurance company would drop her if she made any more claims. I wrecked her car due to unfortunate events where a random person entered her vehicle and demanded that I drive. So, I drove and hit a large concrete flowerpot causing major damage to her car that night. The random guy got out and took off. The police charged me with wreckless driving. My friend is saying that she will sue me for damages if I don't agree to pay for repair. Does she have to claim this on her insurance or will I be liable for damages? Her car is not paid for. I agreed to pay the deductible but, I cannot afford to pay for the total costs of repair. Also, I was her DD that night

+ Read More

Attorney answers 4


Let her sue you. Unless you are Daddy Warbucks, she will likely go ahead and make the claim with her insurance.

Click on name or picture to see profile page.


You should consult with an attorney in Georgia where you live. No doubt you can find a personal injury attorney who offers free consultations. You should rely on advice from individuals in your jurisdiction as the law differs from state to state.
Even if your friend turns the claim into her insurance company, there is still the possibility that the insurance company will pay her claim for the car; drop her as an insured; and sue you for the damage you caused. Not sure how far the random guy portion of your story is going to get you.
If you are sued by your friend, or her insurance company, a judgment stemming from a motor vehicle accident can affect your right to a driver's license. Best advice -- call a GA attorney.


NEVER listen to someone who says "don't call my insurer." Call them, since they may actually pay the claim. As a general rule your "friend" (and I use the term loosely) will not be able to sue you when the insurance is handling it (although it is possible you might be sued by the insurer, or sued by her for the deductible).

(A note: you have posted this question over and over. Once is plenty).


Even if she reports it to her insurance company, there is some potential for you to have to pay for the damages if you were found at fault. However, if the accident was caused by the person who got in the car that night, you would not have to pay. You were not clear in your question on what caused the accident itself. In the end, it is more a practical issue. If you do not have the funds to pay and she wants her car fixed, she will have to report it to her insurance company, which is her responsibility to do in any event. Also, she would not likely find an attorney to sue you, although she could file a claim in small claims court.

Get Avvo’s 3-part personal injury email series

A roundup of the best tips and legal advice.

Personal injury topics

Recommended articles about Personal injury

What others are asking

Can't find what you're looking for?

Post a free question on our public forum.

Ask a Question

- or -

Search for lawyers by reviews and ratings.

Find a Lawyer