Skip to main content

Malpractice Settlements Third Party

Brunswick, GA |

I couldn't get an attorney for my medical negligence case because they said even though I suffered a loss, it would be too costly and difficult to prove although I had witnesses. I pressed the issue with the hospital and they now want me to talk to their "third party" to settle it. He called and asked for billing statements and medical records. I know he works for the hospital but how does this work? How much information should I give him and how do I get what's fair. They asked me for a dollar amount but I haven't given one.

+ Read More

Attorney answers 4


If your case in in Brunswick, there is good reason that lawyers turn it down. In the entire history of Brunswick all the way back to colonial days, apparently there has never been a jury verdict in favor of a plaintiff in a medical malpractice case. One local lawyer who incurred the wrath of the local medical community was blacklisted so that no local physicians would even treat his children. Moreover, at least 80% of all medical malpractice cases that go to trial statewide in Georgia are won by the defense. Since medical malpractice cases are always expensive, difficult and time consuming, the case has to be very clear and extremely catastrophic to be worth pursuing. I'm not sure what you are referring to as a "third party" unless it is a "third party administrator" who manages claims. However, I am absolutely confident that they have no intention of doing anything that you would consider fair.



Thank you so much for your honest and candid response. In addition to letting me know about negligence law suits in general, I found the information about Brunswick quite interesting. (I wonder it's anything like that in Michigan and South Carolina.) At least I now have an idea of what I'm dealing with. Again, thank you.


If you are not willing to hire a medical malpractice attorney on a contingency at the full rate, you may want to consider trying to get help with valuation either at an hourly rate or some type of reduced contingency. It would be impossible for an attorney to guide you through the process in response to your post. It's obvious that an attorney needs to review all of the available information and advise you accordingly.

Good luck.



Thank you but I believe you misread my FIRST sentence. I did not write that I was "not willing to hire a malpractice attorney".


The hospital risk management may be willing to pitch a few thousand dollars to you, depending of course on the nature of your injury & expenses. They are asking for the medical charges so they can justify this sort of payment to you. Of course, they may very well later tell you that they decline to make any offer. If you take money from the hospital at this point, you are likely forever barred from suing them in the future should you later get a lawyer.

Malpractice cases are very expensive to pursue. That doesn't change just because you have a witness to the incident. Medical experts must be hired, depositions taken, court reporters paid, videographers paid, court filings incurred, etc. These cases cost tens of thousands of dollars to litigate. If a reasonable settlement value of your case is, say, $10, wouldn't make economic sense to lawyer up and spend $30,000 just to get a $10,000 settlement. This may explain why your last attorney bowed out.



I was told that by one attorney He used the example that since I wasn't dead, it didn't make since to spend $100 just to win $10. Thank you for responding.


I will second the other posters comments that medical malpractice cases are extremely expensive and complex. Thanks to many of the tort reforms that have been enacted, claims for medical malpractice that involve non-catastrophic injuries are very difficult for injury attorneys to take on.

I would suggest you continue to call around to more injury attorneys who do medical malpractice work. It is difficult to give you any real evaluation of the case based on an internet post, but the reality is that bargaining with a hospital on your own is no picnic. After you resolve your case, either through representation or on your own, I would suggest calling your local congressman and asking him/her to vote against tort reform legislation that prevents many attorneys from being able to help people legitimately injured at the hands of a negligent doctor, nurse, or other medical provider.

Get Avvo’s 3-part personal injury email series

A roundup of the best tips and legal advice.

Personal injury topics

Recommended articles about Personal injury

What others are asking

Can't find what you're looking for?

Post a free question on our public forum.

Ask a Question

- or -

Search for lawyers by reviews and ratings.

Find a Lawyer