3 out of 4 roommates (me included among the 3) signed a 6 month lease back in January. Recently the landlord wanted to evict one of those 3 roommates and said that because the 4th roommate refused to sign the lease, we were all Tenants At Will and that there was no lease. He never gave us a copy despite of us asking him to do so numerous times. When I moved in I did not pay last month and security deposit. 4 months later the landlord has now asked me to pay him, and I was getting ready to do so, but upon knowing that we have no lease I had reservations about this and was wondering whether I am still required to give payment to the landlord. The landlord wants me to stay and sign a lease in August and has been asking me to pay now for last month/security deposit via email. Should I ?
Family Law Attorney
Last month and security can be asked for in a tenancy at will, but is not required. Now that tenancy has started, though, LL is in a difficult position to ask, although could evict on his theory that you are now at will, if you refuse. However, then I would question whether you are at will if you and LL both signed the lease, unless the lease required all tenat signatures to be effective. Anyway, unless you want this to blow up and be a mess, this is all a matter of negotiation with the LL. Why can't he give a lease now if that was his intent originally?
To questioners from West Virginia & New York: Although I am licensed to practice in your state, I practice on a day-to-day basis in Massachusetts. I answer questions in your state in areas of the law in which I practice, and in which I feel comfortable trying to offer you assistance based on my knowledge of specific statutes in your state and/or general principles applicable in all states. It is always best, however, to work with attorneys and court personnel in your own area to deal with specific problems and factual situations.
4 lawyers agree
I would not put down a last month/security deposit without having a signed lease. Although your landlord is entitled to ask for them, if anything goes wrong and he fails to properly maintain the deposit, it will be more difficult for you to prove the wrongdoing in court without written documentation. If you think that your LL is a trust-worthy guy, and that he honestly isn't trying to trick/screw you over, it might be worth paying him simply to keep the peace. However, the fact that he wants the security deposit and last month rent now, rather than when you initially almost signed the lease, is a bit suspicious.
Given that he wants you to stay and sign a lease in August, I suggest you ask for the lease now. It would be simple for the LL to alter it so it runs from April-August. Once you have the signed lease in hand, then you can write him a check.