Through an e-mail, I agreed to art work for an advertisement for our company. That was in March 2012. Then in May BEFORE it went to print, I told them many times that I wanted to cancel our ad. They said they spent time on it and had to make changes and updates from the previous ad that we placed in a college student planner. However, there were not changes made, it was the same ad as the previous year. And again, it hadn't gone to print. Now the advertising firm is billing me and now sent it to collections. Saying that my verbal response is legally binding and I have to pay. Do I have to pay for this? Do they have a legal leg to stand on?
The query is confusing. In a short answer, a verbal contract is binding if it represents a meeting of the minds and depending on the amount and terms. In most states, over a certain amount the "statute of frauds" applies, meaning that such contracts are not enforceable unless in writing. There are other terms that bring the statute of frauds into play. Here, it is unclear what you refer to as your "verbal response." If you agreed to pay for advertising orally and you later cancelled the order, the advertiser may well have a claim for "quantum meruit" meaning the value of its services up to the time of cancellation. You should determine what, if any, services they provided in reliance on your order before the cancellation before paying them. Good luck!
3 lawyers agree
Contracts / Agreements Lawyer
I agree with my colleague both that the other party may have an equitable claim based on work completed and that a verbal contract can form a binding contract, but that it could be subject to the statute of frauds (meaning that a "writing" is required and that you must "sign" it to be bound by it). Whether the statute of frauds would apply depends on some more specifics (such as whether or not the "contract" contemplated that it would be completed within a year). An e-mail can in some circumstances satisfy the writing requirement of the statute of frauds. Whether or not they have a leg to stand on depends on more specifics.
All communications are provided for general informational purposes only, may not be applicable to your specific set of facts, and do not constitute legal advice or a legal opinion, or form an attorney-client relationship. You should not act or rely on any information provided through this website or the Internet in general without first obtaining legal advice from an attorney specifically hired to represent you on a given matter. For more information, go to www.theARgroup.com.
2 lawyers agree