His mother and sister have contacted me and not in a nice way to give the ring back. Legally do I have to give him the ring back? He is threatening to sue me for it.
Divorce / Separation Lawyer
Unfortunately, yes. Wisconsin has ruled that an engagement ring is a "conditional" gift with the condition being marriage. If the marriage does not occur, regardless of the reason, you are required to return it or pay him for the value. Sorry.
2 lawyers agree