IN FL WHEN BEING STOPPED BY A COP IS IT ILLEGAL TO NOT SHOW YOUR LICENSE OR REGISTRATION, RATHER GIVE YOUR NAME /ADDRESS ORALLY?

IN FL WHEN BEING STOPPED BY A COP IS IT ILLEGAL TO NOT SHOW YOUR LICENSE OR REGISTRATION, RATHER GIVE YOUR NAME /ADDRESS ORALLY? Giving that showing your license & or registration can be direct violation of 4th Amendment?? IN WHAT CIRCUMSTANCE MUST YOU PROVIDE YOUR LICENSE OR I.D in FLORIDA???

Orlando, FL -

Attorney Answers (6)

Michael Charles McGinn

Michael Charles McGinn

Criminal Defense Attorney - Tampa, FL
Answered

When stopped by law enforcement for a traffic stop you are required to produce your Driver's License upon request. It is not a violation of the 4th Amendment. If you have a valid license and do not produce it you can be charged with driving without a license.

If you find my answer to be helpful or the best answer, please make sure to mark your choice. **COMMUNICATION ON... more
Michael Adam Haber

Michael Adam Haber

DUI / DWI Attorney - Miami, FL
Answered

My colleagues are all spot on. There is no 4th Amendment Violation where a police officer condcts a traffic stop and requests your relelvant driving documents. In fact, as a consequence of your operating a motor vehicle you are required, upon request, to produce 3 items (a driver license, a registration certificate and proof of insurance). Your failure to produce any of these items can result in a non-criminal traffic infraction; but, should you further refuse to sign a citation, then your refusal to sign can result in your being arrested for a 2nd degree misdemeanor (see Florida Statute 318.14). In the event thatthe traffic stop was unlawful (i.e. the officer stopped you illegally, or in violation of case law) then your citations for failure to produce, including you refusal to sign, may be dismissed as what we call the "fruits of the poisonous tree".

In non-driving contexts, absent law enforcement's resaonable (and articulable) suspicion - or probable cause - that you have committed, are about to commit or are in fact committing a violation of law, you are free to reject law enforcement's requests to either speak with you or to present proof of identification.

You should be aware that what happens on the street and what happens in court often prove to be mutually exclusive.... Thatis to say that many a poilice officer resign themselves to the adage that "you can beat the rap but you can't beat the ride". Accordingly, you are almost always best advised to be polite and cooperative, but not to incriminate yourself in the process.

Jonathan Matthew Witt

Jonathan Matthew Witt

DUI / DWI Attorney - Maitland, FL
Answered

Various sovereignty groups have tried this argument in the courts, and so far, they haven't had much luck. The Fourth Amendment argument only applies to searches and seizures the court deems "unreasonable." Courts have found there isn't anything unreasonable about asking to see ID/registration during a traffic stop.

For more information or to set up a free consultation contact the Witt Law at 407-205-WITT (9488). This answer... more
Bryce Aric Fetter

Bryce Aric Fetter

Criminal Defense Attorney - Winter Park, FL
Answered

If asked then feel free to say no. If ordered to do so--like during a traffic stop--then you must show your license with your picture on it. There is a civil statue that requires this. You must show your insurance card and registration too upon demand.

www.BryceFetter.com

Mark H Randall

Mark H Randall

DUI / DWI Attorney - Longwood, FL
Answered

You are suppose to have these documents on you when you drive. If not it is not criminal, but it is an infraction.

Andrew Vincent Coviello Jr.

Andrew Vincent Coviello Jr.

Criminal Defense Attorney - Land O Lakes, FL
Answered

In Florida when stopped by police you'll be your driver your drivers license proof of insuranc an and registration do your utmost to avoid sovereignty laws or quote tha UCC, yes I've seen pro se litigants do that, as they have no bearing and or Criminal and or Criminal Code.

Questions? An attorney can help.

Ask a Question
Free & anonymous.
Find a Lawyer
Free. No commitment.