i want to know if when i went to an emergency room while i was on vacation out of state and had a problem with that body part if that can be revealed or is only florida records.
If you have an attorney, this is the kind of question that they should be able to answer specifically for you. Sometimes the answer depends on the injury and the case, but generally, yes, once you have placed your physical condition (an injury) at-issue, the other side in the lawsuit gets discovery of all records about your health.
If you have an attorney, you really should be asking him or her. If you are trying to "go it" alone, your really should get an attorney. Generally speaking though, if you are claiming injuries, all your medical records they can find are "fair" game for discovery purposes. It doesn't matter if you got treatment in Florida, Washington, or even out of country for that matter. Additionally, despite a requirement physicians keep your records for a certain number of years before destroying them, many seem to keep them longer. So don't bank on the fact you didn't get treatment in the last ten (10) years for a condition, there may still be records documenting the same.
The short answer is yes. If you place your physical or mental condition in controversy in a lawsuit most medical records are discoverable. There are certain exceptions to the general rule. You need to talk to your attorney about your concerns, or if you haven't retained an attorney I would suggest talking to one about your specific concerns.
Discovery is generally very broad they will in all likelihood be able to entitled to review the medical records from the other state. But just because they will be entitled to review them, does not necessarily mean they will be admissible at a trial should your case go that far. If you haven't already hired a local personal injury attorney, I would suggest that you may want to consider doing so as they will be familiar with the evidentiary rules and will know best how to handle your particular situation.
Discuss all issues with your lawyer. In NJ and NY, you can be asked to sign authorizations permitting the release of a broad amount of information and records as long as the request is reasonably calculated to lead to relevant evidence. Good luck.
Matthew C. Simon, Esq.
The Law Office of John Tierney
1259 Route 46 East
Building 3, Suite 133
Parsippany NJ 07054
Anytime you are in litigation, and you have some type of injury, you have placed your condition at issue to where your records may be discoverable. As the others pointed out, assuming you are represented, your attorney is in the best position to answer this. Generally, the rule in most jurisdictions is anything calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence is discoverable, or can be obtained.
Yes. They can see them. They will see them. They will use an industry database to find all claims you have made. They will subpoena all your medical records.
You are basically asking for advice on if you can get away with unethical and illegal (insurance fraud is a crime in Florida) conduct. Any lawyer that tells you should try to do that, should be disbarred!
Get free answers from experienced attorneys.
24,130 answers this week
2,489 attorneys answering
Don't speak legalese? We define thousands of terms in plain English.Browse our legal dictionary