Skip to main content

How does the jury know what is legal and not legal?

Miami, FL |

my case is in regards to a physician who was importing counterfeit medical products into the country in his suitcase and passing them off as real. I found out they were counterfeit after I suffered injuries. The dr provided an affirmative admission that its counterfeit. On stand he says he does it all the time, he doesn't have a problem with it. A lot of the trial was convincing the jury that it is perfectly fine. But it is illegal! Both Under Florida Section 499.005 and SEC. 30121 U.S.C. 331 How are they to know it is illegal? Also, how are they to know that affirmative admissions are to be taken as fact regardless of testimony?

it was also unanimous from both my side and defenses side that the injuries were directly caused by the medical procedure where he used the counterfeit product. I lost. The defense successfully convinced the jury that importing the counterfeit medical products and using them on his patients without their knowledge is perfectly normal. But it is not, as a matter of law.

Attorney Answers 3


  1. Obviously, our system of justice is an adversarial process. So the defense gets to say "it's legal" and here is why we think so. And then your attorney would say, "It's not legal and here are our experts who say so, here is the evidence, here is the written statute saying it's illegal, here is the court document where the doctor was criminally convicted for violating said statute, etc" And then the jury decides who is right. Every attorney on this website can give you examples of juries rendering ridiculous, illogical verdicts despite the provided evidence.


  2. The court instructs the jury as to the law, usually including the prescribed method (process, sequence) of analysis and the required standard (quantity, quality) of proof. In some states, the juries hear the instructions of law orally from the bench. In others, they are also provided a written copy of the court's instructions for use during deliberations.

    Juries make bad calls all of the time. Every case I ever lost was for that exact reason. The remedy is to timely appeal if there are legal grounds that are likely to succeed, and to roll with the punches if there are not. Our system of justice promises a day in court for those who hang in and hold out for that. But the system does not promise a correct result, only the opportunity to try for one.

    My responses to questions on Avvo are never intended as legal advice and must not be relied upon as legal advice. I give legal advice only in the course of an attorney-client relationship. Exchange of information through Avvo's Questions forum does not establish an attorney-client relationship with me. That relationship is established only by individual consultation and execution of a written agreement for legal services.


  3. It is hard to know from the information you provided what persuaded the jury - for example we don't know what your damages were. However, it sounds like they may have had difficulty establishing a connection between his admitted use of the misbranded medical product and your injuries. Violation of a statute can be evidence of negligence but the rule in many jurisdictions is the jury can find that it isn't negligence. That sounds like the case here. In order for a plaintiff to prevail on the issue, the jury would have to find that violaton of the statute was, in fact, negligence and then find that the negligence directly caused the harm alleged. It sounds like they didn't get past the first part of the equation.

    The answer to this question is for informational purposes only and is expressly not legal advice. This information is not intended to create, and receipt of it does not constitute, a lawyer-client relationship. Readers should not act upon this without seeking advice from professional advisers. http://stevensonlynch.com/

Professional ethics topics

Top tips from attorneys

What others are asking

Can't find what you're looking for?

Post a free question on our public forum.

Ask a Question

- or -

Search for lawyers by reviews and ratings.

Find a Lawyer

Browse all legal topics