How does having history of anxiety or depression weaken any malpractice claim?

Asked about 2 years ago - Miami, FL

Have been told that history of anxiety weakens my malpractice claim.

Additional information

Even though claim is orthopedic issue. Is it because mild psychiatric problems like anxiety reduces the credibility of plantiff's testimony even though completely unbiased testimony from anyone is an impossibility. Or is it because depression causes somatic pain so defense seys well you're not feeling the pain from the surgery complication you're feeling pain from your history of depression.

Attorney answers (5)

  1. Charles B. Upton II

    Contributor Level 15


    Lawyers agree

    Answered . A history of anxiety should not weaken a malpractice claim, particularly one related to an orthopedic issue. The question is whether your treatment met the relevant standard of care. In other words, it's not about you; it's about the doctor. If you are not represented by an attorney, I would be happy to speak with you.

    If you would like a free consultation about your issue, you may call me at 850-727-5964 or email me at cbu@... more
  2. John David Kelner

    Contributor Level 10


    Lawyers agree

    Answered . I disagree with Mr. Upton a bit. All Medical Negligence claims have a 'pain and suffering' component to them as damages. To use a measurement for this hypothetical, if you had two quarts of anxiety and depression before and now have three quarts, they will pay (if found liable) for ONE quart of the anxiety, not all three. Two were pre-existing having nothing to do with the medial negligence EVEN IF YOU WIN.

    Since most med neg attorneys take cases like this on a contingent fee and get paid a percentage only if they win and on what they win, a pre-existing injury may lower the damages. Further if there is a credibility issue of 'he said-she said', having a psychiatric history may cause a jury to believe the other person if there is nothing else to go on to figure out who to believe. THAT may affect the win or loss of the claim.

    Speak to an attorney who knows medical negligence. If your case has been rejected by someone who knows this field because of that reason, it is likely a damage issue or that the fault proof is too difficult or this history will affect your believability on some issue.

    This is not intended as specific legal advice to you or about your case. The only way to provide that is for you... more
  3. Keith G Langer


    Contributor Level 19


    Lawyers agree

    Answered . MedMal cases are quite complex and are "battles of the experts;" yours and your former doctor's. Their experts will likely argue your pain is a function of your pre-existing depression; your expert will argue that you suffer physical pain from a negligent orthopedic procedure.

    You need to discuss this with an experienced medmal attorney. Contact the FL and Miami bar associations for referrals.

    The foregoing is for general information purposes and does not establish an attorney-client relationship.
  4. Christian K. Lassen II


    Contributor Level 20


    Lawyers agree

    Answered . It may reduce it slightly, but without knowing all the facts and circumstances, I couldn't give you a complete analysis.

    Only 29% Contingency Fee! Phone: 215-510-6755
  5. Martin Paul Weniz

    Contributor Level 13


    Lawyers agree

    Answered . Regardless of how it may affect your case, you should still seek legal counsel to review the pertinent details of your case and understand your rights moving forward.

Related Topics

Negligence and personal injury

Negligence is a key concept of injury liability, and occurs when someone fails to take a reasonable amount of care to avoid injuring others.

Medical malpractice and personal injury

Medical malpractice occurs when a medical professional's negligence causes injury to a patient. Incorrect actions and inaction can both be forms of negligence.

Jonathan Michael Rolnick

Medical Malpractice Case

There is an expectation when we see a physician or go to the hospital that a certain "reasonable" standard of care will be provided. In most cases, this is exactly what happens. There are... more

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask a Lawyer

Get free answers from experienced attorneys.


Ask now

25,670 answers this week

3,026 attorneys answering

Ask a Lawyer

Get answers from top-rated lawyers.

  • It's FREE
  • It's easy
  • It's anonymous

25,670 answers this week

3,026 attorneys answering