In Florida, there are three requirements for an enforceable postnuptial agreement: (1) there is no fraud, deceit, duress, coercion, misrepresentation, or overreaching; (2) the agreement is not unreasonable or disproportionate; and (3) both spouses completed full and fair financial disclosure or had knowledge of the other’s finances. ---Case: Casto v. Casto, 508 So.2d 330 (1987)
My case does not meet (2) of the requirements.
I was forced under duress and coercion to sign a post-nup.
Plus we did not give each other a financial disclosure.
I also understand to prove coercion is practically impossible but if I have an affidavit from a family member that witnessed the event would the Postnup still be enforceable?
Not providing full financial disclosure (or being afforded the same) can be enough to set aside a pre-nup. Duress would have to be proven based on the circumstances leading to your allegation. For example, timing is a relatively easy way to prove that you were under duress (ie if it was signed a few days before the wedding), but in most cases one would have to look at the specific facts surrounding why you are claiming duress.
Family Law Attorney
If what you allege can be proven with competent and credible evidence, you have a classic case to set aside the antenuptial agreement. Also, whether you were represented in the review and execution of the agreement is relavent, as well as the amount of time you had to reciew the agreement before you signed it. Nevertheless, you must sit down with a lawyer to more closely assess your case and know exactly how to proceed
If I would add a few things to what my colleagues have said. I think that no disclosure is easier to prove then duress. The key is the amount of non-disclosure, such as whether you knew the extent of your spouses's assets. Factors that you have not mentioned may also be important. For example, the length of the marriage, your own financial situation, whether or not you were represented by an attorney.
Family Law Attorney
You have gotten good advice from all of the lawyers answering, One additional thing to keep in mind in regard to your decision to litigate this issue: truth has no real impact on a decision made by the Court in family matters but the " perception of truth" is everything. That is to say, the two most important words in our practice are " prove it". Simply knowing what you believe to be true will get you nowhere unless your witnesses testimony can establish an appearance of the truth. Be sure to have your testimony in line before you decide to invest in this fight. If we can help call 954 522 1922 for Brawer, Hirsch and Assoc. PA
DISCLAIMER STATEMENT FOR ANYONE READING THIS BLOG OR QUESTION POSERS ON AVVO: The response to questions posted on facebook which are responses to questions submitted by anonymous persons on AVVO are in no way intended to establish any form of attorney-client relationship with either the anonymous AVVO question submitters or any facebook readers nor should they rely on this information in any pending legal matter. The responses given are deemed as responses to general questions and fact scenarios posed as an educational exercise only, should in no way be deemed legal advice provided to any persons in states in which the author is not licensed to practice law or viewed as a solicitation of clients from those states in which the author is not duly licensed to practice law, should not been deemed as psychological counseling advice or psychological advice for which this author is in no way qualified to provide nor should any reader rely on any such information without first seeking advice from an attorney at law, licensed in the state of the reader’s residence in regard to any information posted or from a licensed qualified psychiatrist, psychologist, mental health employee, licensed clinical social worker, marriage counselor or other persons licensed by their respective state to provide mental health advice. To the best of the author’s knowledge the questions may well be generated for pedagogical purposes only and not necessarily posted from real persons seeking legal advice.