How can I invoke privilege for email communications when negotiating items with the other side's attorney?

Can I ask the other attorney to agree that it would be privileged before I negotiate? To be sure it is privileged do I get his agreement in writing or is email good enough? I don't want the negotiations via email to end up at our court hearing.

Los Angeles, CA -

Attorney Answers (3)

Michael Raymond Daymude

Michael Raymond Daymude

Litigation Lawyer - Sherman Oaks, CA
Answered

It is wrong to assume that written settlement communications you have with opposing counsel are privileged. It is not. So, your attempt to claim a privilege that does not exist is futile. However, nothing stated in settlement discussions (written or otherwise) can be admitted to prove liability or to prove the invalidity of plaintiff’s claim.

If you chose to be cautions, you can label any written communication which contains settlement terms or discussions (via email or otherwise): Confidential Settlement Negotiation (or similar), Evidence Code sections 1152, 1154. That will highlight the fact that you view the communication inadmissible to prove liability. Still the communication could be admitted for other purposes, either in total or part.

I am licensed in California only and my answers on Avvo assume California law. Answers provided by me are for... more
Nicholas Basil Spirtos

Nicholas Basil Spirtos

Construction / Development Lawyer - Montclair, CA
Answered

There would be no privilege, but settlement discussions are not admissible at trial, so just label your emails as settlement discussions and then if opposing counsel tries to use it against you, you can object.

Neil Pedersen

Neil Pedersen

Employment / Labor Attorney - Irvine, CA
Answered

Mr. Daymude is correct. If your communications are an attempt to settle a matter, mark the email clearly as "Settlement Negotiations" so that you and the court later can easily know that the particular email was part of the negotiations. Then move to exclude any of the communication at that time.

No agreement is required to invoke the right to exclude the settlement communications at the time of trial.

Good luck to you.

This answer should not be construed to create any attorney-client relationship. Such a relationship can be formed... more

Questions? An attorney can help.

Ask a Question
Free & anonymous.
Find a Lawyer
Free. No commitment.