Hello, I have a question about a current situation that I am involved in. I made a stupid decision, and probably the worst one of my life. Last week on Friday I shoplifted at a Macy’s department store. I was attempting to take two sweaters which values totaled to be something like 250$. But I used a pair of needle nose pliers to take off the sensors and damaged the products. The total civil demand that Macy's charged me for is 583$. I did not have my wallet ID or anything on me when I was caught except my cell phone, keys, the pliers, and a Macy’s gift card that I had found which ended up having no money on it. The loss prevention staff questioned me about my intents and I was scared so I tried to cooperate as best as possible by signing a bunch of papers. I admitted that I planned on stealing and claimed the pliers as mine in order to cooperate in hopes of easing the process. Later the police arrived and arrested me and took me to county jail. I was charged with burglary. I am now out on bail and my court date is this Monday. This is my first offense and I have no previous criminal record. I am a full time college student and have a 3.5 consistent GPA. I am, however, not currently working but am getting a job within the next week. So given my situation, my questions are; what are my next steps when I go to court? What should I say and do you think I will be able to reduce the charge from a felony to something lower? Should I plea not guilty before my public defender is assigned to me? I am sorry I am clueless when it comes to the system. Any help would be so gratefully appreciated. Again, thank you so much in advance.
Ok, first thing is calm down. You may have been arrest for a felonies but it could be charged as misdemeanors. You need a skilled criminal defense attorney who knows the courts and the prosecutors and what they are willing to do in the way of pleas. If you (or your parents) can’t afford a private attorney the court will appoint a licensed attorney call the public defender. The PD will help you. Get your grade cards and resume together and give a copy to your attorney. You need to be packaged as the good kid who did something foolish, once. The pliers are going to be an issue, it shows planning. These cases are really hard to predict. It really depends on what the DA, or city prosecutor wants to do.
Hopefully, the prosecutor will allow some form of informal diversion. You may have to do a bunch of community service/labor in exchange for a dismissal. Most importantly your attorney will have to work to have this not be a felony conviction. Felony convictions dramatically alter your civil rights and future potential. With misdemeanors you will still have issues if there are convictions for theft related charges. If you use the services of the PD listen very carefully to what they say. Don’t BS with them or they mentally may move on to the next case. A good PD can do wonders on a case. They work with the calendar DA day in and day out.
If your parents have the resources then hire the best skilled, experience, and knowledgeable criminal defense attorney who practices in the court where you case is set. A private attorney can spend the time packaging and positioning the case. But, make sure that attorney know the court and the prosecutor.
First thing though is calm down and relax. Keep your expectations about this realistic. This will be in your life in some form. There will be an arrest. Most likely the charges will get expunged, which in California is a very weak form of relief. But, you will survive and move on beyond this.
First of all, please don't barf so many details about your case on public websites, where anyone in the world can read them.
When you go to court on Monday, you should ask the judge to appoint an attorney from the Public Defender's office... then let your lawyer do the talking. Your lawyer will have all the facts of the case and can talk to the District Attorney handling the matter... which means your lawyer can do a lot more to help you than a stranger on the Internet who doesn't have that kind of access.
The "civil demand" issue is completely separate from the criminal case, and you can probably just ignore them. There are a handful of law firms that work on a commission basis for stores; if the law firm collects, they keep a percentage of the money and send the balance to the store.
Expenses, like printing and postage, come out of the law firm's share... so they usually give up after a couple of letters go unanswered. I have never heard of a single lawsuit filed in California because somebody refused to pay these outrageous civil demands... and even if they did sue you, they couldn't justify charging you more than $500 under these circumstances.
See my legal guide, below, for more information on civil demands.
When you do hire a lawyer or accept a public defender, make sure that he or she doesn't accuse you of "barfing" when you talk about your case. Such an individual is an insensitive prick who will not do much to help you. And you will need help based on the facts you have imprudently published here.
One wonders why if one is a "stranger on the Internet" one would keep posting on subjects he admittedly knows nothing about.
Get free answers from experienced attorneys.
18,549 answers this week
2,435 attorneys answering
Get answers from top-rated lawyers.
18,549 answers this week
2,435 attorneys answering