Does an affirmative defense constitute an admission

Asked over 2 years ago - Chicago, IL

I am working on an answer to a complaint where the Plaintiff has lied and has a different version of events from me. I would like to respond with an Answer, Counter-claim, & affirmative defenses. My answer denies the majority of the allegations & my counter-claim alleges my version of the facts that state my cause of action.

I would also like to add in some affirmative defenses. But I am worried that they would be regarded as admissions? (b/c aren't affirmative defenses considered YES, I DID, BUT...?).

What I really want to do is deny the Plaintiff's allegations, say my version, and say i am not liable because.... (ie. say, No I did NOT, but, if the court was to find that I did, then here is why i should still not be liable).

Any help would be appreciated.

Attorney answers (4)

  1. Robert Thomas Kuehl

    Pro

    Contributor Level 13

    2

    Lawyers agree

    1

    Best Answer
    chosen by asker

    Answered . An affirmative defense is not a denial. Rather, it is something that gives color to the other side’s claim (essentially admitting its sufficiency) and then sets forth some new matter exculpating the defendant from liability (statute of limitations is one example).

    Any affirmative defense would have to be set forth in your answer. If that answer is verified, any fact admitted in it would constitute a judicial admission that would be binding on you, and incontrovertible.

    Limited scope legal representation (sometimes referred to an “unbundling” or “unbundled legal services”) is permitted in Illinois. It allows an attorney to provide some but not all legal services. Specifically, Illinois Rule of Professional Conduct 1.2(c) provides as follows: “A lawyer may limit the scope of the representation if the limitation is reasonable under the circumstances and the client gives informed consent.”

    With respect to the lying, see Illinois Supreme Court Rule 137--http://www.state.il.us/court/supremecourt/rules... (I am assuming this is a case pending in state court).

    I strongly encourage you to seek out and retain an attorney.

    Good luck.

  2. Paula Brown Sinclair

    Contributor Level 20

    4

    Lawyers agree

    1

    Answered . No, affirmative defenses are not admissions. Sometimes affirmative defenses have nothing to do with the varying versions of events.

    Your ambition to learn enough law on short notice to represent yourself is admirable, but you are playing with fire. The public information available on Avvo complements of the good-hearted attorneys to provide answers can't begin to meet your needs. Nothing short of a full case review consultation and probably representation will be sufficient. Some attorneys provide "unbundled services," meaning they would be willing to prepare your answer and counterclaim for a modest fee. This might be effective for the time being, but then you will be getting into discovery and trial preparation and needing to ask similarly basic questions about civil court procedure.

    Best wishes for a favorable outcome, and please remember to designate a best answer.

    This answer is offered as a public service for general information only and may not be relied upon as legal advice.
  3. Pamela Koslyn

    Contributor Level 20

    3

    Lawyers agree

    1

    Answered . No, affirmative defenses aren't admissions. Admissions are admissions. Afformative defenses need to part of your answer, and there's little downside to including them other than that you may have to respond to discovery requests about them, whereas if you omit them, they'll be waived.

    Also, a counter-claim requires more than simply disputing the plaintiff's alleged facts-- you still need causes of action entitling you to some relief, and if you lack those, you're setting yourself up for demurrers or motions to dismiss.

    If this regarding a contract and the plaintiff has a lawyer and your contract has an attorney's fee clause, you really need to hire your own lawyer. I agree with my colleague that this isn't a DIY job. If plaintiff has a lawyer, you're going to get out-litigated, and quite possible quickly, and if you make mistakes and/or protract the litigation, you'd be on the hook for their side's fees. If you get your own lawyer and plaintiff is trying to DIY this, you can be the one that does the out-litigating and gets to add on the legal fees.

    Avvo doesn't pay us for these responses, and I'm not your lawyer just because I answer this question or respond to... more
  4. Daniel G. Galivan

    Contributor Level 17

    Answered . Affirmartive Defenses are not admissions. Assert them at the end of your Answer, before the counterclaims, under separate heading "Affirmative Defenses." www.galivanlaw.net

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask a Lawyer

Get free answers from experienced attorneys.

 

Ask now

28,780 answers this week

3,134 attorneys answering

Ask a Lawyer

Get answers from top-rated lawyers.

  • It's FREE
  • It's easy
  • It's anonymous

28,780 answers this week

3,134 attorneys answering