Discovery for motor vehicle violation

Went to court for a traffic summons out of Sandyston, NJ 4 lst appearance. I had previously made a discovery request to the Prosecutor for the town in which the violation occurred. He sent the request to the State Police for everything I asked for but has not received anything, yet. When I went to court, the Prosecutor I spoke with was from another town, not the one in which I received the summons. It's a joint municipal court. He claimed that the things I requested were not discoverable (video, audio, all written and electronic documents, etc). He was trying to tell me that the audio and video aren't relevant. But they are and I don't know how he can determine that if he wasn't there. If I don't get what I requested and paid for, how do I compel them to give it to me? Thanks

Montague, NJ -

Attorney Answers (4)

Matthew R Schutz

Matthew R Schutz

Speeding / Traffic Ticket Lawyer - Flemington, NJ
Answered

I agree with Counsel. R.7:7-7 Governs discovery in Muni Court. You will need to file a motion in order to enforce your request. Suggest you retain Counsel to help you.

James Edward Schroeder III

James Edward Schroeder III

Speeding / Traffic Ticket Lawyer - Egg Harbor City, NJ
Answered

You are entitled to discovery under the court rules but it often takes a while to get these documents from the State Police. If this goes 5-6 months then you certainly should ask the Judge to dismiss the case.

It would be helpful to know what are the specific charges you are facing.

Jim Schroeder is licensed to practice law in New Jersey and the District of Columbia. All information provided... more
Mark M Cheser

Mark M Cheser

Speeding / Traffic Ticket Lawyer - Union, NJ
Answered

The prosecutor does not control discovery or what is relevant, the Court does. File a motion for discovery. if the judge grants the motion and it is not porovided you can move to dismiss. If the court denies the motion you can appeal the denial. You do not mention the charge. i'm guessing it is a mnor moving violation. What you are doing is unusual so the system will balk at first. All State Police cars have video and it is discoverable.

James Alexander Abate

James Alexander Abate

Criminal Defense Attorney - Westfield, NJ
Answered

File a motion.

Law Offices of James A. Abate Jabatelaw.com (732) 412-2364

Questions? An attorney can help.

Ask a Question
Free & anonymous.
Find a Lawyer
Free. No commitment.