I received a notice in the mail that the DA's office had discovery materials that were available for me to pick-up (I did not make the request). Thinking that it was my blood results, I picked up the documents. It turns out that the documents are not my blood results but rather documents detailing how the lab had significant errors in their results between 11/2011 and 3/2012 (my DUI arrest was 8/2012). Included in the documents is a list of all the retests and emails/docs detailing the investigation.
My question is, how does this affect my case? It has been 10 weeks since my arrest, I have already been to my arraignment (DA had me plead 'Not Guilty') and I still have no blood results.
DUI / DWI Attorney
The Colorado Department of Health Blood Lab is in a lot of upheaval due to faulty testing. Even though your test was performed after the dates on the letter, it may be possible for a good DUI atorney to successfully argue to a jury that your test result is also invalid. There are a lot of factors involved in defending a DUI case. You should at least have a competent DUI attorney look at the discovery you received. You can call the CDPHE blood lab at 303-692-3680 to find out your blood alcohol level.
8 lawyers agree
Divorce / Separation Lawyer
I agree with my colleague. Often times, DUI cases are attacked by a thousand cuts. This is one more cut that a competent attorney can use to attack your case at trial. You should seriously consider either retaining an attorney of your choosing, or applying for a public defender, if you do not have the funds to hire someone else.
Nothing in the answer provided should be considered legal advice because all cases and facts are different and require a thorough examination of the facts by an attorney before any decisions are made.
6 lawyers agree
DUI / DWI Attorney
There is no one in the business better than Gary Pirosko. You should call him for a consultation. Bottom line is that without an experienced DUI Defense attorney, this letter means little to nothing to you as you will not know how to use it or exploit the problems at the lab.
It affects your case as it brings into question the entire process of blood testing and the reliability and credibility of the test result. The lab recently acknowledged that they made errors on over 1,700 tests and there is reason to believe the numbers go well beyond that. The best advice that any of us can give you is to fight this case and to hire the best DUI Defense attorney you can afford.
The Orr Law Firm, L.L.C - 303-818-2448 - Is Colorado's Premier DUI and Criminal Traffic Defense Law Firm. Rhidian Orr is the senior partner and owner of the firm and focuses his practice exclusively to DUI and criminal traffic matters in the state of Colorado. His decision to answer your questions does not constitute an attorney/client relationship. The Orr Law Firm offers FREE Consultations and we encourage that you contact his firm to discuss your case in more detail.
3 lawyers agree