Criminal Case: Home Invasions, Self Defense What's Allowed?

Asked over 1 year ago - Seattle, WA

I have always known to be true that with like force only, lately all I hear is if there is an home invasion, intruder, that it seems to be o k to fire at will.

What is the truth, is it still with similar force only, or once that door, entry is violated then at [that] early point it's considered a safety risk?

One case comes to mind, the one recently in the news where the woman was home with her children and went to hide in the attic and fired 5 times and the perp fled.

Again, if she was hiding, then how would she know if her life was in danger, isn't that the over riding fact of self defense, you can not bring a gun to a feather fight?

Law suits what they are, what if a perp makes a case that well gee, I was just here to take some cookies and the crazy homeowner just starts firing!

Attorney answers (4)

  1. Kenan Lee Isitt

    Contributor Level 14

    6

    Lawyers agree

    Answered . A resident has the right to defend himself or herself and property, but if a resident shoots and injures or kills an intruder, the police might just charge the resident with assault, manslaughter, or murder. The resident's beliefs or opinions about use of force are not going to be a factor in the police or prosecutor's decision on whether to charge, and there is no way to provide a guideline for whether a particular use of force is justified: it is always a decision that is going to be made after the fact. Fair or not, that is how it works.
    There is no duty to retreat prior to using force in Washington, but any use of force must be reasonable under the circumstances. The prosecutors are the people who make the decision whether to charge, and ultimately the jury would decide what is "reasonable."
    Some simple (intentionally vague) rules to live by are 1) Don't shoot if you don't have to; and 2) do not unlawfully enter another person's home, because you might get unlawfully shot.
    A burglar is very unlikely to succeed in a lawsuit against a homeowner who shot him or her, but it is certainly possible if the facts are very compelling. Your example about the cookies and crazy homeowner is not very compelling.
    Also, generally, most people who are being burglarized are going to believe that their life is in danger, so the fact that a person is hiding in the attic just reinforces the determination that the person believed that her life was in danger. The police and prosecutors are likely to agree. If the burglar has left the home and gets shot by the homeowner while fleeing, then that is a completely different situation.

  2. Jessica Lorene Campbell

    Contributor Level 13

    5

    Lawyers agree

    1

    Answered . No one really wants to answer your question. Most likely because you seem to either be considering burglarizing some poor woman's house for cookies and wondering if you will be shot or are considering shooting someone in your own house. I highly advise against either scenario, but the short answer is: Washington allows the "castle exception." Google it.

  3. Patrick Owen Earl

    Pro

    Contributor Level 18

    3

    Lawyers agree

    Answered . Reasonable force to defend yourself, family and property is the standand. These matters are very fact specific and there is no way to PRE determine the correct responce to a given set of facts because there are too many variables. If something happens then consult an experienced criminal defense attorney.

  4. Stephen Ross Cohen

    Contributor Level 20

    4

    Lawyers agree

    Answered . Reasonable force depends on the fact situation for example if a grown man comes into your house with a knife and comes to close shoot the bastard. But if a ten year old is trying to steal a bicycle out of your backyard do not shoot, I can not give you much more help as the fact pattern really depends on the amount of present or perceived danger

    My name is Stephen R. Cohen and I have practiced over 38 years and can be reached at 213-819-1171. I practiced... more

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask a Lawyer

Get free answers from experienced attorneys.

 

Ask now

29,609 answers this week

3,041 attorneys answering

Ask a Lawyer

Get answers from top-rated lawyers.

  • It's FREE
  • It's easy
  • It's anonymous

29,609 answers this week

3,041 attorneys answering