I was recently cited with a failure to yield ticket in a collision. I was turning left on a yellow light when a driver trying to make it through the yellow light (as opposed to slowing down) crashed into me. He claimed that the light was green, but I have several witnesses on the sidewalk who agree with me, that the light was definately yellow. But the officer said that this doesn't matter, and I am still at fault. This intersection is one that I use all the time, and I had checked to see other people slowing down before starting my turn; I just hadn't seen the other car speeding up. The officer who issued me the ticket told me it was my fault, but I could try to get my ticket dismissed on the grounds that it is my first accident (though I've gotten one speeding ticket before), but how likely is it for a judge to dismiss a ticket for this reason? Is there anything else I can do to get this ticket dismissed--assuming that I am representing myself and not hiring an attorney (no funds)? If I do contest the infraction and fail, what are my options then?
Secondly, I noticed that the officer didn't issue the other driver a ticket for not having written proof of insurance on him. He just got the infomation off the phone from his mom and repeated it to the officer who added it to the case report. The officer also wrote my phone number wrong on the case report. The insurance thing strikes me as unfair at best but more importantly, does this affect the case at all? Also, is it imperative for me to call to correct the number on the report? (The other driver wrote down my info separately and has the correct number, so I'm not worried about that)
It's my first accident, so I'm very worried, as well as inexperienced with the whole procedure. Any help is much appreciated.
Car / Auto Accident Lawyer
A few preliminary things. Make sure you get checked out if you were injured in the collision. Also make sure you've contacted your own insurance company to report the collision if you haven't yet. Most policies require you to do that to ensure coverage of the collision, under the "duty to cooperate" section.
OK - turning left at an intersection means you yield to all oncoming traffic. It is lawful to pass through an intersection with a traffic control device (stoplight) when it is green or yellow. When the light becomes red, your car must have entered the intersection for it to be considered illegal.
That being said, you were probably at fault. One factor which may contribute to the other driver's negligence is if you had established yourself in the intersection with enough time and space for him to safely stop his car in time to avoid a collision. That would require testimony of an eye-witness that could say without question he had enough time and opportunity to avoid hitting you. Again, this would not remove fault from you, but would split it between you and the other driver.
Getting your phone number wrong might be enough to get the ticket dismissed, but most judges would overlook such a small detail - especially since many people give officers the wrong number. Your name, the location of the infraction, the law cited on the ticket - get these wrong and it is likely the judge will dismiss the ticket.
The fact that the other driver didn't get cited for no insurance? It has nothing to do with whether you merited receiving a ticket or not, and won't be factored in at all.
One option you might consider is requesting a deferment. To defer the prosecution of an infraction means your asking the court for 12 months to prove you're a good driver. Get through the 12 months without another ticket, and this one falls away. Get another ticket during the 12 months? Then you pay for both plus court fees. I
f you suspect a ticket may be possible inside 12 months, ask for mitigation. Explain to the judge that you were doing what you thought was right and that you are generally a very cautious and careful driver. Most judges will reduce the amount of the citation by roughly 50%.
Also be aware that deferment can only be used once every seven years, and you still have to pay a court fee of $100. If the cost of the ticket is relatively small, get it mitigated, pay it, and be done with it.
Child Abuse Lawyer
Mr. Shaw gave such a thorough answer that I only have one thing to add: addressing your concern re: the other driver speeding. Case law indicates that if speeding only brought the other driver from point A to point B earlier and did nothing else to contribute to the accident, it's not a factor. I agree that it may most likely be considered by your insurer and the other driver's insurer in determing whether to apportion fault. But it does not exonerate you for liability.
Lawsuit / Dispute Attorney
It's not a great idea to represent yourself in traffic court. You do, however, have the constitutional right to do so. I would recommend spending an entire day in the traffic court to observe how judges handle self-represented defendants to get an idea of how irritated they get at amateur lawyering.
If you really want to represent yourself, you should purchase an hour of a traffic attorney's time to have her or him coach you on how to handle things.
A better choice is simply to hire an attorney.