Just curious to know why some companies charge tax online for orders and others don't? I heard at one point that if the store was not available in the county/city where the online order was made then there is no tax. EX: Macy's. I buy a pair of shoes online from Macy's. No tax is charged since there's no Macy's store in Jacksonville (i guess it's not). Is this assumption correct and if so then what to do when companies violate this rule?
Employment / Labor Attorney
This is quite complicated. Technically, the internet is still the Wild West. However, vendors are supposed to charge sales tax if they have a "brick and mortar" store in your state. If not, they can get away with not charging sales tax. However, even if they don't charge sales tax, you are STILL RESPONSIBLE legally for the sales tax and are supposed to report it and pay it as a "use tax", which I can say that perhaps nobody does and I have never heard of any action against anybody as a result of it. As for Macy's, I don't know why they didn't charge tax. They have stores in Florida and should be charging sales tax in Florida. Most likely, it is Macy's that can get in trouble not you even though you are technically responsible for it as a "use tax".
This answer is subject to the terms and conditions provided by AVVO. Also, it does not create an attorney-client relationship in any manner whatsoever. In connection with any potential claims, an attorney should be promptly contacted to obtain more specific advice and to ensure that any applicable statutes of limitation do not expire which would prevent you from seeking relief on one or more of your potential causes of action.
2 lawyers agree
I agree with attorney Address. If the vendor has a physical presence in the state they should charge the sales tax, if they do not they do not charge it and the purchaser is responsible to pay a use tax which is the equivalent of the sales tax. While many people do not pay the use tax, many states are cracking down on this.
Any individual seeking legal advice for their own situation should retain their own legal counsel as this response provides information that is general in nature and not specific to any person's unique situation. Circular 230 Disclaimer - Advice given in this response cannot be used to eliminate penalties with the IRS or any other governmental agency.
1 lawyer agrees