Can unemployment compensation decision be presented to EEOC and/or court in support of a discrimination argument?

I was fired from my job allegedly for "Poor Academic Performance". UC sent me the following decision notice: In situations where the Claimant is discharged for unsatisfactory work performance, the burden of proof is on the Employer to show that the Claimant had been warned about the unsatisfactory work performance and was not working to the best of his ability. In order to qualify for benefits once this is established, the burden shifts to the Claimant to show good cause for the unsatisfactory work performance. In this case, the Claimant worked to the best of his ability. As a result, the Employer has not sustained its burden of proof. Benefits must therefore be allowed under Section 402(e). Is it of any legal value as a supportive document?

Philadelphia, PA -

Attorney Answers (2)

Edward Clement Sweeney

Edward Clement Sweeney

Employment / Labor Attorney - Downingtown, PA
Answered

Not much. An unemployment decision is (1) almost never binding on a case of discrimination and (2) decides different issues than raised in a discrrimination case. It does not seem clear to me that this particular UC decision even speaks to issues of discrimination. More information is necessary.

Terence Sean McGraw

Terence Sean McGraw

Social Security Lawyers - Blue Bell, PA
Answered

A UC decision could potentially be used to prove a relevant factual issue, but in this case, no. The issue in the UC case was whether your performance was so poor that it rose to the level of willful misconduct. The fact that it did not does not mean that your performance was not, in fact, poor. Nor does it mean that your employer could not have honestly believed your performance was poor. It proves only a legal conclusion specific to the UC law.

This answer to your legal inquiry is based upon the limited facts stated in your question. Accurate legal advice... more

Questions? An attorney can help.

Ask a Question
Free & anonymous.
Find a Lawyer
Free. No commitment.