We saw this house for sale, a short sale. We moved forward and provided with all information needed for the loan, got approved. Sold our assets cheap to come up with the deposit fast. We have to request 3 extension on the short sale because the seller didn't have the power of the attorney. Two days before the last extension expires, she gets it. The loan is funded and then the money is returned because the seller has a bankruptcy which she fail to let the agent to know. She claims is dismissed, and it is not. Now the negotiator doesn't want to extend the short sale. They want to start from the beginning which means an appraisal which will come back at a higher price (very likely). We can afford a higher price, and we might loose the house and the good rate. Can we sue the seller?
Estate Planning Attorney
My standard response to "can we sue ___" is to say yes, you can always sue anyone you want for anything you want. The important question to ask and have answered is "can we win." To provide you a reliable opinion as to the validity of any causes of action in a forum such as this is really not possible. I do, however, believe that you have a strong case for breach of contract, though short-sales are very strange animals. First, depending upon how the purchase agreement was drafted, the bank who must approve the short-sale essentially becomes a party to the sale, and tends to drive the transaction. The seller is likely liable for failing to disclose the existence of the bankruptcy earlier in the transaction. The damages for that failure to disclose may be paying a higher price for the home, or worse, losing the home altogether. I have to assume that she was in bankruptcy to save the home, and if she dismissed it and now you have to start the short-sale negotiations over again, there is a possibility that the home could be foreclosed before you get to close escrow. In that case, again, you may have a cause of action for damages resulting from her breach of the purchase contract. The problem, of course, with a forum such as this is that we have no ability to review the documents related to your purchase to determine to what extent the seller is not liable for actions taken by the bank. I've reviewed a lot of real estate sales contracts in short-sales, and though most agents use CAR forms, I've seen enough of them drafted in other manners that I couldn't hazard a guess in your case. I strongly recommend that you contact a local real estate attorney to review your contract and give you a reliable opinion as to what your rights are, and the propriety of continuing forward in this transaction, or cancelling and pursuing damages. One past point - if the Seller is in bankruptcy, before you spend the time and money to chase her with a lawsuit, look at the paperwork filed with the Bankruptcy Court. She may not have any assets with which to satisfy a judgment resulting from a lawsuit.
David L. Gibbs, Esq.
The Gibbs Law Firm, APC
San Clemente, California
*Due to the limitations of the Avvo.com Forums, The Gibbs Law Firm, APC's (the "Firm") participation in responding to questions posted herein does not constitute legal advice, nor legal representation of the person or entity posting a question. No Attorney/Client relationship is or shall be construed to be created hereby. Further, information you provide to the Firm through this website is not confidential - it is available publicly to anyone visiting this website. The Firm shall have no obligation to keep the information you provide herein confidential in any context. The information provided herein by the Firm is general, and requires that the poster obtain specific legal advice from an attorney. The poster shall not rely upon the information provided herein as legal advice nor as the basis for making any decisions of legal consequence. As required by 11 U.S.C. §528, we must now disclose that, "We are a debt relief agency. We help people file for bankruptcy relief under the Bankruptcy Code. Assistance we provide with respect to Debt Relief may involve bankruptcy relief under the Bankruptcy Code."
1 found this helpful
5 lawyers agree
Real Estate Attorney
No way to say unless all documents are reviewed by an attorney. As discussed in other responses depends on lots of factual (contractual) issues.
You should consult with real estate attorney to weigh all you options. Good luck.
In addition to AVVO's disclaimer, please note that by this answer no attorney client relationship is intended mor entered into and unless there is a signed retainer agreement in place, neither me nor anyone in our office has intended to solicit clients nor reprints them. The answers are general in nature and without weighing specifics of particular query. No answer should be relied on in whole or in part, directly or otherwise to act or not to act in pursue of any of your potential claims in law or equity. You should consult with and obtain advise or representation of an attorney to protect your rights regarding your case or matter.
1 lawyer agrees