While I don't think the problems with your feet are a sufficient basis to suppress the field sobriety tests (FSTs) , those problems would certainly be powerful impeachment of the arresting officer, his knowledge of correct procedure and protocol and ultimately, the evidence on which probable cause to arrest was based. If he was informed of your foot ulcers and decided to administer the tests anyway, that shows poor judgment on his part and would imp[act the usefulness of those tests as indicators of impairment. You should consult an attorney experienced in DUI defense.
Please note that this is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. This post represents only the poster's opinion. You should speak to an attorney for further information. The poster is licensed only in the State of Washington. For more information about our law firm and services, please visit my website at www.brodskylawfirm.com. I hope this post was helpful to you. Thank you.
I would say the most judge's are unlikely to suppress (throw out) field sobriety test results for the reasons that you give as they go to the weight to be given the evidence, not it's admissibility.
That being said, such a medical condition as you describe would likely have a profound affect on your ability to perform the Walk-And-turn or the One-Leg-Stand test, so I would imagine that your attorney would have a lot to work with when attacking those results in front of a jury.
The same could be said of the officer's observation that you watery, bloodshot eyes.
The argument can be made and the Judge would decide. Usually the Judge would allow the testimoney but the issues and reasons for things would place your field tests in a different category then just completely negative. The Jury would have information that there were other reasons for the results of your test so it would make them less of a factor. Compare that with the rest of the potential testimony from the officer and maybe you have a winner. Get an attorney for sure.
What you're talking about goes to how much weight that evidence will have rather than whether it will lead to getting the evidence thrown out. I look for a judge to allow a prosecutor to use that evidence but allow you to explain the additional facts you stated above.
Talk with an experienced DUI attorney about this case. Most DUI attorneys will offer a free initial consultation, so take advantage of it.
Craig Cahoon The Cahoon Law Office, PLLC 206-795-1779 email@example.com
A roundup of the best tips and legal advice.