Can I file a suit for defamation/libel/emotional distress?

Asked over 1 year ago - Santa Rosa, CA

I was alleged to have sexually harrassed a subordinate. My employer ultimately settled the suit as a business decision to avoid the high cost of going to court. I am innocent of these charges but did not get my day in court to defend myself. Now I am left with the allegations in a public document alleging despicable acts that I did not commit.

Attorney answers (4)

  1. Patrick John Phillips

    Contributor Level 17

    5

    Lawyers agree

    Answered . I'm sorry this happened to you. Unfortunately, parties to a lawsuit are generally protected from claims for defamation arising from statements contained in their pleadings. This is known as "litigation privilege." Thus, it is unlikely that the misrepresentations contained in these court documents could form the basis for a libel claim.

    The most likely cause of action would be one for malicious prosecution (the act of bringing a lawsuit without good cause for the purpose of harassing or intimidating the other party). However, an essential element of such claim is termination of the lawsuit in the defendant's favor. Since your employer settled the suit, I don't see how a cl aim for malicious prosecution could be supported.

    http://www.johnphillipslaw.com

    This answer is a general interpretation of the law and is not fact specific to your case. Likewise it does not... more
  2. Christine C McCall

    Pro

    Contributor Level 20

    5

    Lawyers agree

    Answered . Probably not. Your co-worker's report to your employer is not subject to claims of defamation for a number of reasons including (1) CA Civil Code section 47; (2) the requisite element for defamation of 3rd party publication; and (3) the strong public policy favoring reports of the kind of misconduct that she alleged. Suing on these grounds will inevitably bring an anti-SLAPP motion and you can wind up on the hook for the defendant's very considerable legal fees.

    As for suing your employer, your employer did not make the statement and was legally required to investigate it. Your employer had the discretion to believe it or not -- the law did not dictate a result in that effort. It is wholly unlikely that your employer published the statements of that employee in any matter that would meet the requirements of publication to any 3rd party. So, it is highly unlikely that you have any sound legal claim against your employer, most especially if you were not terminated based on the allegations.

    You will see a lot of reference to defamation in employment contexts here on Avvo. Many of those references are incorrect and not based on actual hands-on experience litigating defamation claims. Civil Code Section 47 is a powerful problem for the defamation plaintiff to overcome and, in the employment context, the requisite publication to a 3rd party is not accomplished by reporting or repeating the allegedly defamatory statements to others within the employing entity.

    You are not incorrect to feel that you have been injured and to want to know where is your remedy. This is a common situation and represents a difficult but unmistakable (and controversial) policy choice in the law.

    You may want to schedule a consultation with a defamation-experienced employment attorney to discuss these issues in further and exacting detail. If you do, ask during that consultation about the potential for claims against the accusing co-worker based on interference with contractual relationship and interference with prospective economic benefit. These are slightly less problematic for the plaintiff than defamation. But, in truth, unless your evidence is truly jaw-droppingly awesome in its strength and conclusiveness, taking on the burdens of plaintiff and going after the complainant on these facts will almost inevitably make your situation significantly worse rather than better.

    No legal advice here. READ THIS BEFORE you contact me! My responses to questions on Avvo are never intended... more
  3. Christian K. Lassen II

    Pro

    Contributor Level 20

    3

    Lawyers agree

    Answered . Unlikely, but call one of the above lawyers to discuss.

  4. Orfelia Maria Mayor

    Contributor Level 8

    2

    Lawyers agree

    Answered . I would see an attorney in your district.

Related Topics

Emotional distress caused by personal injury

Emotional distress refers to the negative mental effects an injury has, including fear, loss of sleep, depression, and other effects.

Personal injury and defamation

Defamation is any type of emotional or psychological personal injury that occurs when someone intentionally harms another’s character or reputation.

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask a Lawyer

Get free answers from experienced attorneys.

 

Ask now

19,401 answers this week

2,550 attorneys answering

Ask a Lawyer

Get answers from top-rated lawyers.

  • It's FREE
  • It's easy
  • It's anonymous

19,401 answers this week

2,550 attorneys answering