Skip to main content

Can I be sued for back mortgage payments?

Billings, MT |

My ex girlfriend and I bought a house over three years ago. We split up two and a half years ago and I left the house. She has been living in it and paying the whole mortgage sense I left. She finally got a hold of me last December saying she wanted to get this worked out. I put down the entire down payment to get into the home in the first place, so after a few days of negotiation we agreed for her to give me back my down payment and half the furniture and I wouldn't worry about any equity that was built because I didn't build it anyways. The day before signing the house, she changes her mind and says a lawyer told her she can sue for half the mortgage for the last 2+ years and wasn't going to give me anything. Sounds sketch to me but wanted some legal advice.

Attorney Answers 2

Posted

If as you say you put up the entire down payment and you are both on the mortgage, then you may have what is called an "oral general partnership" with regard to the house and the mortgage obligations. That means that unless she's contending the downstroke was a gift of some kind she would theoretically owe you 1/2 the "equity" back and you'd owe her 1/2 of the mortgage payments to date, in which case you'd also split whatever the paydown of principal was over that time period, which is probably negligible. At the same time in part depending on how you were named on the deed you are theoretically entitled to occupy the house as an owner too, so that should also work in your favor, because if she is occupying the whole house then theoretically she owes rent (or use and occupancy) on the ownership interest that is yours, and I would argue that her making mortgage payments in part represents such compensation and not entirely hers as equity "appreciation". However, since she has now gotten an attorney involved and while you can still try to work it out with her directly my suggestion is to also get counsel.

Mark as helpful

Posted

Assuming you were both on the title, what you would probably be facing is a partition action. The goal of the partition action is the divide the property between two people accounting for what they've put in to it and what it's worth now. It often involves the sale of the property, or one party buying the other out.

Without knowing more facts about the numbers involved, it's difficult to say where things would play out between the down-payment, the mortgage payments, and the current equity/value of the house. I'd suggest you sit down with an attorney if you think she's going to seek payment for you or if you think you're entitled to some money and want to get it from her.

Mark as helpful

Sued for debt topics

Top tips from attorneys

What others are asking

Can't find what you're looking for?

Post a free question on our public forum.

Ask a Question

- or -

Search for lawyers by reviews and ratings.

Find a Lawyer

Browse all legal topics