Scenario: My friend's husband owned a property from previous marriage. Surviving spouse/husband recorded a Quit Claim Deed to himself as Trustee of a Trust. Husband re-married to my friend in 12/1996. My friend was never on the Trust or Title. Husband died Jan 2012. Can my friend benefit from the house since California is a Community Prop State? Also, he is supposed to grant the Quit Claim Deed to the Trust not to him as a Trustee, right? My friend is now being evicted by the Successor Trustee (daughter from previous marriage). What can she do at this point?
Your questions actually overlap both estate planning law and family law. Brief answers (in order) are as follows:
1. Your friend was married from December of 1996 through January of this year, and it sounds like she was living in the house owned by her husband during that time. The house was owned by husband's trust, which I am assuming was a revocable (i.e. changeable) living trust he created to hold his property separate from his marriage. Assuming that there was no pre-marital or pro-nuptial agreement where your friend agreed that his property would remainlly exclusively his property, it is possible that she was acquiring a 50% community property interest in the growth in the value of the house from the time that she became married. This could occur if either her husband's salary or wages and/or her own salary or wages from work was being used to make mortgage payments, pay taxes and insurance and maintenance on the property. This is because community property laws in California provide that, in the absence of an agreement that says otherwise, income from employement is owned 50/50 by husband and wife regardless of who is actually earning the income. This would mean that one-half of the money used to maintain the house may have legally belonged to your friend as her share of community property.
The second question is simple. The Quitclaim Deed should have been titled to your friend's husband as trustee of his trust, as he did. Granting title just to a trust makes it unclear who actually has the authority to borrow against or subsequently sell or transfer the property, which could cause major problems later on.
As for the third question, if your friend did acquire a community property interest in her deceased husband's property, especially after 15+ years of marriage, then she is a part owner of the property and legally cannot be evicted from the property. This is because ownership of real estate carries with it a right to possession of the property, and she would be an owner not a tenant.
Your friend needs to consult with a family lawyer immediately concerning the community property issue, and likely an estate litigation attorney to assert her possible ownership rights in the eviction proceeding. Because evictions can proceed very quickly, she needs to act right away.
Our office has maintained a family law practice in Alameda County, Santa Clara County and Contra Costa County for the past 31 years. I have represented several thousand of individuals in family law matters.
Mr. Bergman's response to your inquiry is very informative. By and large what we are talking about here is a pro tanto community interest that may be acquired in a property even though your name is not on the ownership. The solution to the problem may not be real simple. It's most difficult to bring claims into family law court once someone has passed away. Very, very few exceptions exist and the rights will probably will have to assessed in the parameters of the Probate and Trust Department of your local court jurisdiction and or in a separate independent action against the successor trustee ascertaining a claim against the property and file a lis pendens with your complaint. Once the notice of pending action ( lis pendens) is filed you will have established a claim ownership in the property and this hopefully would do away with the possibility of a quick eviction.
If you found this answer to be helpful let me know by checking the "Mark as Helpful" box on the bottom of this answer. It's easy and appreciated.
I agree with the analysis of the community property issues, but there is another issue to consider.
Did the deceased husband execute the trust before his marriage to your friend? If so, did he amend the trust or execute a new will after their marriage? If his trust was pre-marriage, and was not amended to provide for, or to specifically state that he was intentionally not providing for your friend, California Probate Code section 21610 states that your friend is entitled to all of the deceased spouse's interest in the community property, and her intestate share of his separate property.
Your friend needs to consult with an attorney experienced in probate matters pronto.
Get free answers from experienced attorneys.
29,138 answers this week
3,085 attorneys answering
Get answers from top-rated lawyers.
29,138 answers this week
3,085 attorneys answering
Don't speak legalese? We define thousands of terms in plain English.Browse our legal dictionary