Better to pay medical bill in full to collection agency or doctor's office and have removed from credit report?

Asked almost 3 years ago - Pensacola, FL

Called the collection agency and was told they were not a collection agency, but the main billing office. Was told nothing has been reported to the credit bureau yet. Found all this to be untrue. I would have to pay the full amount in 30 days to avoid being reported. They also offered I think 20% or 30% discount. Called back the doctors' office if they can get the account back. Since they were updating the system and getting rid of old accounts, they can't. I can only pay them in full within 15 days but no discount and can have the bad credit removed. The bill is $169, but I have huge hospital bills and am unemployed. So paying the collection agency seems like a good deal other than them sounding fishy. Who would be better to pay? Can either of them remove it off my credit report

Attorney answers (3)

  1. Mark Hankins

    Contributor Level 17


    Lawyers agree

    Answered . If you have huge hospital bills you can't pay and no job, paying or not paying this doctor's office cannot have much of an impact on your credit ... even if those hospital bills aren't on your credit they soon will be.

    If you are going to be getting back to work and you need decent credit to be considered for the types of employment you are qualified for (think positions where you handle money, etc.) then you need to declare bankruptcy NOW, before any of those negatives hit your credit report.

    By moving on it now you will have a single negative: bankruptcy.

    However, if that scenario does not apply, you can handle your financial difficulties in a much less formal manner.

  2. Ian Richard Leavengood


    Contributor Level 12


    Lawyer agrees

    Answered . I agree with points made in the above answer. Further to those points, you should focus on the big picture. Settling a few debts now - even if at a discount - likely will not have a positive macro affect on your situation. If you have other large bills and no realistic chance of fighting your way out, use your resources in a more impactful manner. Go consult with a BK lawyer. My only other watch out on the timing of the BK filing - if you are not out of the medical woods just yet, you might want to hold off filing. Good luck.

    This answer should not be construed to establish an attorney-client relationship. Please consult a licensed... more
  3. Kevin V.K. Crick


    Contributor Level 9

    Answered . If this agency lied to you, then they might be the ones ending up owing YOU money. I would not hesitate to get the compensation you deserve under the law in my opinion.

    It sounds like they have violated the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act from what you have described. Feel free to contact me via email, or call my office on Monday, and my firm will direct you to a Florida attorney who can help you for no cost out of your pocket. Sometimes attorneys are also able to have them remove negative trade lines that they are responsible for.

    Please do not take my answer to be legal advice that would establish any attorney-client relationship. Please... more

Related Topics


There are different types of debt, but all involve one person (the debtor) owing money to another (the creditor). Terms of repayment are governed by a contract.

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask a Lawyer

Get free answers from experienced attorneys.


Ask now

21,098 answers this week

2,687 attorneys answering

Ask a Lawyer

Get answers from top-rated lawyers.

  • It's FREE
  • It's easy
  • It's anonymous

21,098 answers this week

2,687 attorneys answering