Amanda Toby Mays’s Reviews

Amanda Toby Mays

Average Rating

Based on 2 reviews

Help make it easier for other Avvo users to choose the right lawyer by sharing your experience with this attorney. It's fast, simple, and safe.

Review this lawyer

Lawyers: Use the Peer Endorsements section to provide input about other attorneys.


  1. Compassionate, understanding and thorough!

    Posted by a Child Support client,
    Overall rating
     Excellent
    Trustworthy
     Excellent
    Responsive
     Excellent
    Knowledgeable
     Excellent
    Kept me informed
     Excellent
    • I recommend Amanda Mays.
    • I hired Amanda 1-3 years ago.
    • Amanda handled my Child Support matter.

    Amanda is a great attorney and worth every penny spent. She is very caring and understanding, even with difficult cases that have lots of issues. None of the issues were glossed over and I felt that she handled everything with professionalism. She was responsive and we were able to settle several issues outside of court which helped reduce the trial time. After the hearing has passed and other issues have cropped up she has been right there to deal with things if needed. I would highly recommend Amanda if you need an attorney!

  2. Run the other way!

    Posted by Mike, a Divorce client,
    Overall rating
     Poor
    Trustworthy
     Poor
    Responsive
     Poor
    Knowledgeable
     Fair
    Kept me informed
     Poor
    • I do not recommend Amanda Mays.
    • I hired Amanda more than 3 years ago.
    • Amanda handled my Divorce / Separation matter.
    • I have previously worked with 3-5 lawyers.

    I used her as my divorce attorney in NJ a few years back. I hired her to fix my child support right away because the way it was calculated on my temporary order was wrong. She kept staling telling me that in 3 months we would fix it at the attorney review panel. I paid her a flat fee and so she was clearly expending the least amount of effort possible. At the attorney review panel it was strongly in my favor but it was clear my child support wouldn't be addressed that day as she had promised. My child support calculation was nearly double what it should have been. So I decided to settle that day if they promised to recalculate it that day. Ms. Mays rushed us in to put the agreement on the record. Which was the dumbest thing ever! She said my ex wife's attorney would draft the final written. Well my support never got recalculated! And to this day I have spend 10's of thousands in court trying to get that agreement honored. My ex's lawyer never wrote up the written and so my I had to go to court to force the judge to write a written agreement based on the transcript. The whole time Ms. mays was buddy buddy with my ex wife's attorney which was extremely unprofessional! She helped my ex stale and stale. And if anyone knows you can never get child support credit retro active!