Skip to main content
Alexander Patton Montgomery

Alexander Montgomery’s Answers

55 total


  • Is it legal for a father to interview his son for a position in the company?

    Two people go in for an interview for an open position in a company, person A meets all qualifications for the job, has past experience of 2 years or better and has no relation to any one in the interveiw process. Person B has lilltle qualificatio...

    Alexander’s Answer

    Business's have wide discretion as to who they hire. Therefore, unless the decision not to hire was due to the applicant's race, color, religion, sex, national origin, or age (if over 40), nothing illegal appears to have happened. It may not be a smart business decision to hire an unqualified family member over another qualified individual but, unless the hiring decision was based upon one of the factors I just listed, it is not illegal.

    Best of luck,

    Alexander Montgomery
    Cornetet, Meyer, Rush & Kirzner, Co, LPA
    Cincinnati, OH

    See question 
  • What is my legal right on seller of home not abiding our contract on repairs to an out building?

    I bought a house in New Franklin Oh. in September of this year. The seller, my Realtor & I drew up a contract on what needed to be done to the house for the agreement on the sale of the house. One of the items that was listed was 2 out building ga...

    Alexander’s Answer

    If the seller breached a provision of the contract, you may have a claim for damages. To determine if you have a claim, however, you will need to have an attorney review the language of the contract. An attorney can explain the contents of the contract to you, determine whether or not a breach has occurred, and your options for moving forward. Best of luck.

    Alexander Montgomery
    Cornetet, Meyer, Rush & Kirzner, Co., L.P.A.
    Cincinnati, OH

    See question 
  • Is it advisable to use an online legal document/advice company?

    I am thinking about using an online legal document/advice site and I'm wondering if these documents will hold up in a court of law? Is it advisable to use this kind of service in place of an actual attorney? Do they have any responsibility if so...

    Alexander’s Answer

    Not advisable. An attorney provides a service, not simply a document like the services you are considering. Not only will an attorney draft a document customized to your situation, but he or she can also provide valuable advice and guidance on what types of documents you may need, identify other legal concerns you may want to think about, and is available to answer any follow up questions you may have regarding the documents or services provided.

    Too often clients have come to me seeking to fix a problem caused by an online document or service. Often times, it's more expensive for me to fix the problem than it would have been for me to provide the service in the first place.

    Stick with real life, qualified attorneys. Not only are you purchasing a better service, but you are also purchasing a piece of mind knowing that an attorney drafted exactly the document you needed.

    Best of luck,

    Alexander Montgomery
    CMRK Law

    See question 
  • Looking for an attorney to do a basic copyright/trademark on a product.

    I distribute an assortment of earrings under a "name" that I would like to trademark so that we have exclusive rights to that name for our display of earrings.

    Alexander’s Answer

    A federal trademark registration certainly would maximize your legal protection in the use of your business name. I've attached a link to an article I wrote explaining some of these protections.

    Many attorneys here on Avvo, including myself, offer a free consultation to discuss the specifics of your application and the costs involved. Feel free to contact any of us.

    Alexander Montgomery
    Cornetet, Meyer, Rush & Kirzner, Co, LPA
    Cincinnati, OH
    amontgomery@cmrklaw.com

    See question 
  • If a company has camera and accuse you of steal and it don't show that you was steal what can you do.

    the employer told another employee that I was fried and I did not get anything in writing what can I do.

    Alexander’s Answer

    The default rule in Ohio is that every employment relationship is "at-will." This means an employer may terminate an employee at any time, with or without notice, for any reason as long as that reason is not unlawful. An unlawful reason would include termination due to race, color, national origin, religion, gender, age, disability, etc. An employee, in turn, may leave his or her employment at any time, with or without prior notice to the employer.

    Unless you had an employment contract, your employment was probably "at-will." Therefore, your employer could fire you at any time, whether you actually stole something or not. Further, termination based on a suspicion of stealing does not appear to be a basis for unlawful termination because, from the very brief facts presented, it does not seem to be based upon any of the above factors.

    If you feel you have been wrongfully discriminated against due to one of the factors listed above, you should contact an employment attorney. If not, however, it appears your termination was legal.

    Alexander Montgomery
    Cornetet, Meyer, Rush & Kirzner
    www.cmrklaw.com

    See question 
  • I signed a contract containing a non-compete clause. When the contract is over in a year, is the non-compete clause void too?

    Non-compete clause

    Alexander’s Answer

    Probably, but like my colleagues have stated, it really depends on what the contract says. Some provisions, especially those concerning confidentiality and trade secrets, are written to survive the expiration of the agreement in perpetuity. Other provisions, like a tolling provision that extends the non-compete clause if you are actually competing, may affect the duration of the agreement as well. Finally, if the duration of a non-compete agreement is deemed unreasonably long, it may be redrafted to account for a shorter time period.

    However, all these things depend upon the wording of the non-competition agreement, which you do not want to post in a public forum. Feel free to contact an attorney to review your agreement. Spending a little money to know the full extent of your agreement could save you thousands of dollars in potential litigation costs should you run afoul of the agreement in the future due to a misunderstanding of its provisions. I've linked an article below with more information on non-competition agreements in Ohio.

    Alexander Montgomery
    Cornetet, Meyer, Rush & Kirzner
    Cincinnati, OH
    amontgomery@cmrklaw.com

    See question 
  • Do I need a lawyer to create an employment contract, or is there a way to do it on my own?

    I just hired a couple of artists and designers, and I may need an employment contract. I recently started a company and we're very close to launching, but we're also very close to the end of our budget. Do I need to have my lawyer draw up the cont...

    Alexander’s Answer

    I have to agree with Mr. Beck and Mr. Rafter. There are too many individualized considerations that may not be and probably are not covered by a simple template. The drafter of the template probably hasn't accounted for every situation that may affect your business. For example, what if your artists and designers are actually considered independent contractors and your contract does not have a work-for-hire provision? Your company may not even own the work those workers create and could be subject to thousands of dollars in copyright infringement liability. Also, do you want your employees to be at-will or subject to a contract of a specific term of employment? An attorney will help you identify these situations and account for them in the contract.

    The money you spend on this contract is analogous to buying insurance. A relatively small amount of money now could save you thousands of dollars in the future. It will also give you a piece of mind and help you avoid unnecessary headaches. When you hire an attorney you're paying for a service, not simply a document you can download off the internet.

    Below I've attached a link to a site I contribute to that covers a variety of legal topics related to startups and existing businesses. It also lists the prices for various services. I hope it can help explain any further questions you may have. Good luck!

    Alexander Montgomery
    Cornetet, Meyer, Rush & Kirzner, Co., L.P.A.
    Cincinnati, OH 45246
    www.cmrklaw.com

    See question 
  • What do I need to do to legally start a small auto repair business from my home?

    I am a mechanic and want to start my own side business to supplement my income.

    Alexander’s Answer

    My colleagues have done an excellent job identifying the most important legal considerations related to starting a business. As they have stated, one of your first decisions is determining which type of business entity to form, filing the appropriate paperwork with the Secretary of State, and getting an EIN. Also, as was mentioned before, the service contract you provide your customers is very important. You'll want to have an attorney draft that document for you so it protects your interests.

    I would only add that you may want to speak with an attorney about selecting a business name that is legally strong if you decide to register your name as a trademark in the future. This is especially important if you will be operating a website. Also, if you get to the point where you may be hiring employees, you may want to consider having them sign a non-compete agreement so that they do not leave your company and start their own competing business down the street.

    I operate a website that has several articles related to virtually every legal aspect of forming a new business. We also offer a free legal survey to identify what services you may need. I've placed a link to that below if you feel it may be helpful to you.

    Best of luck!

    Alexander Montgomery
    Cornetet, Meyer, Rush & Kirzner, Co., LPA
    Cincinnati, Ohio

    See question 
  • Can I ask my former employer to take my picture off the company's website?

    Hi. The company that I used to work for took a picture of me and posted on the website when I was still working there. Now that I have left the company, do I have the legal right to request them to take my picture off? There's nothing like a writt...

    Alexander’s Answer

    It would depend upon the specific facts and circumstances surrounding this picture, but in general Ohio's right of publicity law prohibits the use of an individual's persona for a commercial purpose without that person's written consent (see Ohio Revised Code 2741 et seq. below). An attorney would need to review the picture and ask further questions, but its possible you may use this law to force your employer to remove the picture and, possibly, seek damages related to its use.

    As to the copyright of the photograph, it belongs to the photographer. If the photographer was an employee of the company, the company owns the copyright in the photograph, even if the photograph is of you. However, the right of publicity law I discussed above will usually protect you from the unauthorized use of your likeness.

    If your are truly concerned about the use of this photograph, you should contact an intellectual property law attorney to assist you in getting it taken down. Best of luck!

    Alexander P. Montgomery
    Cornetet, Meyer, Rush & Kirzner
    Cincinnati, Ohio

    See question 
  • Can I be fired from my job without evidence??

    My sister is a manager at Taco Bell. she had dropped money into the safe that night when they closed. The next day the opening manager came in and said $200 was missing. The main manager had watched the video and did NOT see my sister take any mon...

    Alexander’s Answer

    • Selected as best answer

    The default rule in Ohio is that every employment relationship is "at-will." This means an employer may terminate an employee at any time, with or without notice, for any reason as long as that reason is not unlawful. An unlawful reason would include termination due to race, color, national origin, religion, gender, age, disability, etc. An employee, in turn, may leave his or her employment at any time, with or without prior notice to the employer.

    Unless your sister had an employment contract, her employment was probably "at-will." Therefore, her employer could have fired her at any time, even if she had truly not taken any money from the register. Further, termination based on a suspicion of stealing does not appear to be a basis for unlawful termination because, from the facts presented, it does not seem to be based upon any of the above factors.

    If you feel you have been wrongfully discriminated against due to one of the factors listed above, you should contact an employment attorney. If not, however, it appears your sister's termination was legal.

    Alexander Montgomery
    Cornetet, Meyer, Rush & Kirzner
    www.cmrklaw.com

    See question