Skip to main content
Lori Doganiero Palmieri

Lori Palmieri’s Answers

543 total


  • What is a mitigation specialist?

    Are mitigation specialists investigators that try to find mitigating factors (character, mental health, etc.) . Do most attorneys use one for a first degree felony case? Should I ask potential attorneys if they utilize mitigation specialists?

    Lori’s Answer

    I agree with Mr. Olney. Mitigation experts can be a valuable resource for the criminal defense lawyer but remember that all experts cost money, over an above what you pay your lawyer. I find that most mitigation information can be obtained by the lawyer herself, with help from the client and his/her family. Where there are extenuating circumstances of mental health problems, physical or psychological limitations and past history of abuse or trauma, specialized training would be necessary. There is not a set of guidelines used in every case. Each case is unique and will be handled on a case-by-case basis.

    See question 
  • Will an unfingerprinted misdemeanor, never went to station, show up on a level 2 volunteer fingerprinting background check?

    Will an unfingerprinted misdemeanor, never went to station, show up on a level 2 volunteer fingerprinting background check? I was taken into a room, handcuffed, and was and still am very embarrassed. It was for changing a price on an item. If only...

    Lori’s Answer

    What happened to you was that you were "arrested" but released on your own recognizance at the scene with a Notice to Appear in Court. It sounds like you either pleaded guilty or no contest to pay a fine or you completed a diversion program. Either one still results in this criminal charge being part of the public record in the county where it happened. If it is in Miami, check the clerk's website to see if your name comes up. Just because you were not fingerprinted at the jail does not mean that this record doesn't exist. You are likely eligible to have it sealed or expunged and should look into that process. If you answered "NO" to the questions on the school volunteer form about prior arrests or criminal charges, this could certainly come back to haunt you. See a lawyer and find out what your options are to get rid of it permanently.

    See question 
  • Am i legally required to show for pretrial?

    Being the victim, and i have a mandatory subpeona for pretrial, do i have to legally show up for pretrial? Will the case get dismissed then if i dont show? Will i be in contempt?

    Lori’s Answer

    Normally victims are not subpoenaed for a pre-trial conference, but if you have been served, you should appear unless excused. The easiest way to find out is to contact the Assistant State Attorney handling the case and determine if there is a need for you to be present, such as for a motion hearing. If not, I'm certain you will be excused. Either way, you will have piece of mind and not waste your time for nothing.

    See question 
  • Grand Jury Proceedings?

    Since the Grand Jury proceedings are held in "secrecy", how would a defendant know if the prosecutor called witnesses they knew were going to lie under oath to secure an indictment? What if police intentionally wanted to lie to the Grand Jury abou...

    Lori’s Answer

    The grand jury sits between the prosecutor and the accused to determine if there is probable cause to believe a crime has been committed and the defendant is the person responsible. A majority of the grand jury has to vote to indict a person with a crime(s). Defendants absolutely have the ability to testify before the grand jury but it is an extremely rare circumstance. It is a jury trial that determines whether the government has proven it's case beyond a reasonable doubt with witnesses and evidence.

    Also, our system of justice is founded on principles of honesty and integrity especially by lawyers who take oath to uphold the law and act with ethics and professionalism. That is not to say that an unscrupulous prosecutor or cop could not make up evidence but that is certainly not the norm. Our system is still the best in the world and operates to ensure a fair trial. That is why defense lawyers must be on the same footing as prosecutors to challenge the evidence and stand as the last hurdle between the government and the taking of one's liberty. In short, hire a good lawyer.

    See question 
  • Can a defendant still enter the pretrial diversion program even after arraignment

    -is scheduled for pretrial court date already

    Lori’s Answer

    Typically you can apply for Pre-trial diversion after arraignment. That would not be out of the ordinary because otherwise you would have gotten pre-file PTI. After arraignment is the normal course. You should talk to your attorney, or if you have not gotten one, consult with one in your area today. You will greatly benefit from the program. Best of luck from you.

    See question 
  • How do you figure out the florida point system for a capital felony.

    If a person has capital felony charges how do you figure out the point system for florida

    Lori’s Answer

    If a person is charged with a capital felony in Florida, they are facing life in prison. Ask the lawyer representing this person the specifics. The charge could be murder or capital sexual battery - either way life is on the table.

    See question 
  • How long can he be in jail without trial or indictment? Can the charges be dismissed due to speedy trial rights?

    charges: TRAFFICKING IN ILLEGAL DRUGS - 28+ GMS < 30 GMS OF HYDROCODONE & S812.014(2)(C)13 GRAND THEFT OF CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE / Arrest 5/2014, plead not guilty . couldn't afford bail.. Still sitting in jail, 5 continuances for pretrial so far.

    Lori’s Answer

    This case would be charged by "Information" not an indictment. If he has had 5 pretrials, then the charge(s) have been filed and like the other answers, there has to have been a request to continue in one or more of those court dates. On such serious charges this length of time is not unreasonable for the attorney to properly investigate and defend the case. It is unfortunate that the defendant could not post bond, but that again, is not unusual on a 1st degree felony. He should work with his attorney to see how he can resolve the case or take it to trial.

    See question 
  • What do I do in this situation???? PLEASE HELP

    My boyfriend was arrested this past Thursday for Burglary of an occupied dwelling, possession of burglary tools and criminal mischief. The police, jail, court and detectives will not tell him WHAT ,WHERE OR WHEN this crime was supposably commited,...

    Lori’s Answer

    This is when you use your time and resources to hire the best attorney you can. The attorney will lead the investigation into the allegations against your boyfriend, get the witnesses and evidence from the State Attorney's office and give his/her best advice on how to proceed to defend the case.

    See question 
  • How much does a criminal defense lawyer cost???

    Boyfriend is being held on 4 counts of welfare fraud 1 count of possesion of oxycodone and 1 count of sale of oxycodone. I live in another state and I'm just unsure of what and how to help him...

    Lori’s Answer

    You can best help him by doing some research on qualified criminal defense attorneys in the area, looking at qualifications, past experience, years of experience, board certification, awards, and reputation. Then contact a select few that appeal to you on paper and interview them about your boyfriend's situation. Fees will range depending on the lawyer. Your boyfriend is charged with 5 3rd degree felonies and 1 second degree felony, so depending on his prior criminal record, if any, he needs a good lawyer. Remember not to discuss his case with him on the jail phone, as you are being recorded. Good luck.

    See question 
  • Can I get my case dismissed?

    On 5/16/14, I was told I was being baker-acted. Upon detaining me, they found a prescription pill but still said I was being baker-acted. They then put me in the back of a car with someone being taken to jail. On the way the officer still said ...

    Lori’s Answer

    The only time your rights under Miranda apply is if you are in "custody" of the police AND they are asking questions which you answer and incriminate yourself. If you were not advised of your rights under Miranda, you could move to suppress your confession. Just because you were in their custody and allegedly committed an offense does not mean that Miranda protections apply unless they questioned you and you admitted the offense. It appears that you have a possible defense of lack of intent to commit the battery which is an intentional touch or strike against the will of the victim. You need to speak with an attorney about your specific case and what defenses you might have. The lack of reading your Miranda rights will not lead to a dismissal under these facts. Good luck to you.

    See question