Skip to main content

Jonathan D'Agostino

About Me

When I was a child my father, Anthony D'Agostino, lost his leg in a construction accident. He was up on a bulldozer tearing down a building when a brick chimney came crashing down. My family was turned upside down from that tragedy. Over the past 23 years I've built an accident law firm that's dedicated to helping accident victims and their families. My team of over 30 professionals is unique in many ways. First, we don't assign your case to one of our attorneys. When you hire me, you hire my team and will always have 100% access to me personally. As our client you will be given my personal cell # and e-mail address. Why? Simple! Many accident victims today complain that they can never reach their lawyer or that they never get a returned phone call. I want to make sure this doesn't happen to you. You can call me directly or even exchange text messages. Trust me when I say that peace of mind goes a long way!


D'Agostino & Associates consists of five full time Associates and several departments that are specifically trained to handle different parts of your case. We work as a team to make sure you received all the benefits you're entitled to as well as the maximum compensation deserved for your injuries. 


I also have made sure we do not accept or reject a case based on it's size. We have recovererd millions of dollars for many clients and thousands of dollars for others depending on the case. 


If you visit our website at, you will be able to view many client testimonials and case results, as well as tv & radio ads run by our firm. 


Why pick us? There are a lot personal injury lawyers out there who make a lot of promises and can probably get you the same top dollar as my firm, but from the day you retain us till the day we are handing you your settlement check, you will be made to feel like you are our only client. You will be treated with dignity & professionalism, your phone calls returned, text messages & e-mails responded to, and kept informed every step of the way!


With my name on the firm I can promise you that, whether you're calling for yourself, a friend or loved one who has been injured, we will not let you down. 


Languages Spoken: English, Spanish, Italian, Hebrew, Albanian

Practice Areas


  1. Personal Injury: 85%
    26 years, 25 thousand cases
  2. Social Security: 15%
    20 years, 1 thousand cases



Contingent (5-33%), Fixed (Sometimes), Free Consultation (120 minutes)

Attorney Endorsements

3 total 

  • Alena Shautsova

    I endorse this lawyer. Jon is a talented attorney who through his hard work and dedication achieves great results for his clients. I highly recommend him: without doubts he is the one who can win your case!


    Alena Shautsova Employment & Labor Attorney
    Relationship: Worked together on matter

  • No photo

    I endorse this lawyer. I have known Jonathan for many years and he has always been a staunch advocate for his clients. I have referred him several friends and family members as clients and all were extremely satisfied with Jonathan's services. He is committed to getting the best result possible for his clients.


    Edward Pavia Personal Injury Attorney
    Relationship: Fellow lawyer in community

Contact Info

Law Firm of Jonathan D'Agostino, P.C.

3309 Richmond Avenue
Staten Island, NY, 10312-2137


NYCurrently registered 199003/13/2015

Professional Misconduct

We have not found any instances of professional misconduct for this lawyer.
Avvo Contributions
Legal Answers
Award NameGrantorDate Granted
Preeminent 5.0 out of 5Martindale-Hubbell2015
Preeminent 5.0 out of 5Martindale-Hubbell2014
Top Referrals of Business 2011Staten Island Chamber of Commerce Guild 32013
Preeminent 5.0 out of 5Martindale-Hubbell2013
Top Personal Injury FirmWho's Who in Attorneys2012
Athletic Hall of Fame InductionStaten Island Academy2011
Work Experience
TitleCompany NameDuration
OwnerD'Agostino & Associates1990 - Present
Legal counselCross Bay Contracting1989 - 1991
AssociatesRichard P. Neimark, Esq.1986 - 1990
Legal AssistantMcGlaughlin, McGlaughlin & Neimark, Esqs1985 - 1986
Association NamePosition NameDuration
Staten Island Chamber of CommercePresident Guild 3 2011-20122007 - Present
Monmouth Bar AssociationN/A1997 - Present
New York State Trial Lawyers AssociationN/A1995 - Present
Richmond County Bar AssociationN/A1990 - Present
Legal Cases
Case NameOutcome
Staten Island client's attorney: $1.5M settlement a 'win-win result'1.5 Million Settlement
$3.1M settlement and a return of health for Staten Island child who tumbled into pool3.1 Million structured Settlement
Pedestrian settles suit for $1.25M in 4 months!Settlement for $1.25 Million
See all Legal Cases 
Publication NameTitleDate
Staten Island AdvanceWoman Injured as car struck Home sues City for 20 Million2013
Staten Island Advance1.5 Million Settlement a "win-win"2012
Staten Island Advance3.1 mil for Toddler who almost drowned2012
Staten Island AdvancePedestrian settles for 1.25 Million2012
Staten Island AdvanceSon Sues Mom and collects 400K2011
Staten Island Advance375K Settlement2011
Staten Island AdvanceSettlement against sexual predator teacher2011
Staten Island Advance550K for Painter who falls from scaffold2009
Staten Island AdvanceMotorcycle victim accepts 1.1 million2009
Staten Island AdvanceTeens Sue School and Teacher over Abuse2009
Staten Island Advance1 Million Settles Suit2008
School NameMajorDegreeGraduated
Brooklyn Law SchoolLawJD - Juris Doctor1989
Skidmore CollegeEnglishBA - Bachelor of Arts1986
Staten Island AcademyN/AN/A1982
Speaking Engagements
Conference NameTitleDate
Time Warner CableUsing Technology in PI Cases.2013
Staten Island Chamber of CommerceBitten By A Dog? Bite Back!2012
S.I. Chamber of CommerceDid you know 5% Cases go to Trial?2012
Guild 3Risks of Working at Heights -Labor Law Cases.2012
Staten Island Chamber of CommerceWhen to Settle your case!2011
S.I. Chamber of CommerceGetting a Second Opinion2011
Staten Island Community TelevisionMarketing your Firm2010
Staten Island Community TelevisionNetworking2010
SI Chamber of Commerce GuildChanges in the No-Fault Laws2010
S.I. Community TelevisionStress and how to Cope2010
CNNBurned by a Cup of Coffee??2010
BNIWhat is a good lawyer?2009